Progressive groups reacted with disappointment and anger over Jamaal Bowmanâs decisive primary loss to a moderate Democrat in New Yorkâs 16th district, calling for the party to cut ties with pro-Israel lobbying groups they blame for the result.
In a letter to the House Democratic leader, Hakeem Jeffries, more than a dozen progressive organizations said they had âdire concernsâ over the partyâs continued association with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (Aipac), âthe future of the Democratic Party, the future of our multiracial democracy, and the future of our planetâ.
Aipac and its affiliates plan to spend $100m across the election cycle, and Bowmanâs defeat marks their most significant victory to date. Looking ahead, they have already set their sights set on the Missouri congresswoman Cori Bush, who will face Wesley Bell in her August primary. United Democracy Project, a Super Pac affiliated with Aipac, has already spent nearly $1.9m promoting Bellâs candidacy.
The signatories of the letter included the Center for Popular Democracy Action, Jewish Voice for Peace Action, New York Communities for Change and New York City Democratic Socialists of America.
In the letter, they said that in the run-up to the vote, UDP had flooded the Westchester countyânorthern Bronx district with nearly $20m in mailers and ads âfunded largely by Republican billionaires, to drown out Jamaal Bowmanâs message of humanity, dignity, and a thriving future for allâ.
The result, they said, had been to unseat a a candidate that Jeffries had personally endorsed, who retains âa deep well of support among the Black and brown communities in the districtâ, and to replace him with âa conservative politician with a history of racist remarks and governanceâ.
Bowman, a Black former middle school principal who has been an outspoken critic of Israelâs conduct in Gaza, lost to challenger George Latimer by a wide margin of 58% to 42% of the vote. The race was called within an hour of polls closing.
Bowman had been supported on the campaign trail by heavyweight party progressives, including Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the Vermont senator Bernie Sanders, who called the race âone of the most important in the modern history of Americaâ.
Sanders said in a statement after Bowmanâs loss that it was âan outrage and an insult to democracy that we maintain a corrupt campaign finance system which allows billionaire-funded Super Pacs to buy elections.â
âAipac and other Super Pacs spent over $23 million to defeat Bowman. He spent $3 million. That is a spending gap which is virtually impossible to overcome,â he said, adding: âIt is not a coincidence that with our corrupt campaign finance system we also have a rigged economy that allows the very rich to get much richer while many working people are falling further behind. Big Money buys politicians who will do their bidding, and the results are clear.â
Progressives, like Sanders, attempted to characterize the race as an example of big-money influence in politics after pro-Israel groups and a number of wealthy residents of the New York suburban parts of the district weighed in with their checkbooks.
Bush underscored that Latimerâs victory represented a clear threat to the progressive movement, saying in a statement: âThese same extremists are coming to St Louis. They are bankrolling a faux-progressive, former Republican campaign operative to buy our deep blue Democratic seat. But let me be clear: St Louis will not be silenced or sold out.â
The progressive groups said that Aipac had âturned the NY16 race into the most expensive Democratic primary in history, waging an unacceptable assault on our democracy, our communities, and our shared futureâ and called on Jeffries to take action against âdestructive actions in your own backyardâ.
Jeffries, along with most of the House Democratic leadership team, has received Aipacâs endorsement, and the progressive groups demanded that he reject the pro-Israel lobby groupâs financial support to protest against Bowmanâs defeat.
Protect Our Power said in a statement that Bowmanâs defeat was a âloss for young people and anyone who cares about our continued movement toward justice, peace, and building a multiracial democracyâ.
The progressive group blamed âAipac and the Maga billionaires who recruited and paid for George Latimerâs campaign from start to finishâ for the defeat, and vowed âto tell Aipac they have no business creating division in our democracyâ.
In a separate letter of protest, Jewish Voice for Peace Action said it was âsaddenedâ by the results that had unseated a congressman who âhas been one of the few members of Congress committed to defending Palestinian human rightsâ.
âToday is a sad day for American democracy,â said JVPâs political director, Beth Miller. âTo protect progressive candidates moving forward it is essential that Democrats reject Aipac,â she added.
Bob Herbst, a member of the group and a constituent of NY-16, called Aipacâs multimillion-dollar spend in the district âa dangerous interference in our democracyâ.
The race had been viewed as a crucial test of Democratic party unity over an issue that threatens to separate traditionally Democratic-voting Jewish Americans from the party in the aftermath of Hamasâs 7 October attack on Israel that killed nearly 1,200 people, and a nine-month Israeli counter-offensive that has killed more than 37,000 Palestinians and driven hundreds of thousands more to the point of starvation.
Bowman claimed that the results would show âfucking Aipac the power of the motherfucking South Bronxâ, though the Aipac campaign focused primarily on Bowmanâs weaknesses overall and not specifically or solely his stance on Israel. One UDP attack ad against Bowman specifically called out his votes against the bipartisan infrastructure bill and the debt ceiling agreement, accusing the representative of failing his constituents.
âJamaal Bowman has his own agenda and refuses to compromise, even with President Biden,â the adâs narrator says. âJamaal Bowman has his own agenda, and itâs hurting New York.â
Nonetheless, Aipac is using Latimerâs victory to claim that Bowmanâs stance on Israel is why he lost.
âThis race presented a clear choice â between George Latimer, who reflects the views of the Democratic mainstream in his congressional district and across the country, and his opponent, who aligns with the extremist, anti-Israel fringe,â an Aipac spokesperson, Marshall Wittmann, told Axios.
Bowman was no stranger to scandals while in office. In December 2023, he became the 27th House member in history to be censured after pulling a fire alarm on his way to vote on a stopgap spending bill. He was also linked to problematic blogposts that pushed unfounded conspiracy theories about the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. The posts, which Bowman said were from more than a decade ago, were unearthed by the Daily Beast earlier this year and the former representative has since said he regrets them.
Bowmanâs opponent, Latimer, offered a more measured approach in a district with a large number of Jewish voters.
After Latimer accepted his win on Tuesday night, he told supporters: âWe have to fight to make sure that we do not vilify each other, that we remember that weâre all Americans, and that our common future is bound together.â
Joanie Greve contributed reporting