Greece has become the first country in Europe to announce a ban on bottom trawling in all of its national marine parks and protected areas.
The country said will spend €780m (£666m) to protect its “diverse and unique marine ecosystems”.
The Greek prime minister, Kyriakos Mitsotakis, told delegates at the Our Ocean conference in Athens on Tuesday: “We’ve established two additional marine national parks, one in the Ionian and one in the Aegean, increasing the size of our marine protected areas by 80% and covering one third of our marine territorial waters.
“We will ban bottom trawling in our national parks by 2026 and in all marine protected areas by 2030.”
He said he would also establish a state-of-the-art surveillance system, including drones, to enforce the ban.
The proposed Ionian marine national park will cover almost 12% of Greek territorial waters, safeguarding sea mammals like sperm whales, striped dolphins and the vulnerable Mediterranean monk seal and the South Aegean MPA, which covers 6.61% of Greek territorial waters.
However, the Athens government’s decision to go ahead with two new marine parks in the Aegean and Ionian has stirred up tensions with its historical rival Turkey. Ankara’s foreign ministry warned Greece last week that the proposal in the Aegean lay in a disputed area and that the initiative was “politically motivated”.
Conservationists welcomed the announcement and said they hoped the move would create a “domino effect” for other EU countries to do the same.
Nicholas Fournier, the campaign director for marine protection at the international conservation group Oceana, said: “Everyone was expecting France or Germany or Spain to step up. The fact that Greece is championing this ban on bottom trawling is surprising but very welcome.
“We hope this creates a domino effect on other European countries to do the same. The pressure is on France, as it hosts the UN oceans conference next year.”
The news came as France was accused of hypocrisy by conservationists over a post-Brexit dispute with the UK over fishing rights. The country launched an official protest after the UK moved to ban bottom trawling from parts of its territorial waters to protect vulnerable marine habitats.
Charles Clover, the co-founder of Blue Marine Foundation, a UK-based conservation organisation, said: “The grownups of Europe really do need to sort out the extraordinary chaos between its member states over marine protection. France claims to have already protected 30% of its waters – while their own conservationists tell us less than 0.1% of its waters are effectively protected from trawling.
“On top of that, France wants to prevent Britain banning trawling in marine protected areas in the UK’s own waters – which is utter hypocrisy, contrary to habitats laws that apply to both of us and unacceptable to the UK. Today we have Greece leading Europe by announcing that it will actually protect all of its MPAs from trawling by 2030, which amounts to a huge 32% of its waters. Has the EU no common standards?”
Bottom trawling by industrial vessels is a hugely damaging fishing technique that drags heavy nets across the seabed, destroying habitats and releasing carbon into the sea and the atmosphere.
Oceana – along with other NGOs, the Marine Conservation Society and Seas at Risk – has urged the EU to take tougher action against members that still allow bottom trawling in their marine protected areas. A report in March showed that the destructive practice is still happening in 90% of all offshore MPAs in the EU.
At the moment, just 7-8% of the ocean is protected, and only 3% falls under the “highly protected” category.
Some people spend a long time deciding what they want to do in life. Hazel McBride feels lucky that sheâs always known. As a child in Scotland, she watched a VHS tape of Free Willy on repeat. That was the first time she felt a connection with killer whales. The second time was at age eight, on a trip to SeaWorld Orlando in 2000. Shamu was the animal worldâs greatest celebrity, and in the US, SeaWorld ads were ubiquitous. Kids wanted to see the killer whales, and after they saw them, they told their parents they wanted to become killer whale trainers. McBride actually did it.
It wasnât easy. Scotland didnât have a SeaWorld, or warm water, or anywhere, really, where McBride could get experience with marine mammals. She had horses she cared for, and she was on the national swim team â a modest start. She sent out volunteer applications to local zoos and worked with California sea lions at a safari park. She reached out to trainers online and one told her a psychology degree would help, so she got one.
When it was time for her to get âdolphin experienceâ â a rung up the career ladder (and food chain) toward orcas â she interned abroad in the Bahamas and Florida, prepping buckets of dolphin food and giving educational briefings. She graduated from the University of Glasgow and started applying for jobs.
But killer whale gigs are competitive; McBrideâs first full-time gig was still with dolphins, in the Dominican Republic. Then, in 2015, a space opened up on the orca team at Loro Parque in Spain. After a lifetime preparing, she had the career sheâd always dreamed of. She was, finally, in charge of a killer whale.
There was only one problem:Blackfish had premiered.
Blackfish, a 2013 documentary, argues that beneath the feel-good facade of orca shows are sick and miserable whales, and trainers in lethal danger. The film centers the 2010 death of the SeaWorld trainer Dawn Brancheau to make a powerful case against orca captivity.
Orca researchers interviewed in the film say that orcas captured in the wild at a young age become violent, particularly when forced to perform and breed by their captors. Blackfish argues that Brancheauâs killing by Tilikum, a particularly aggressive orca, is a result of SeaWorldâs cruelty toward the social, hyper-intelligent species. Blackfishthen links her death to other fatal orca incidents, including the 2009 death of the trainer Alexis MartÃnez at Loro Parque, McBrideâs employer.
Online, the hashtag #EmptytheTanks proliferated, with fans of the film staging campaigns to pressure corporate sponsors into dropping their SeaWorld partnerships, or singers to cancel their shows at the parks. By 2015, SeaWorld had reported an 84% drop in profit compared with 2014 as attendance shrank.
The impact on the industry went far beyond its best-known park brand. McBride woke up one morning in Spain and found out that orca breeding, one of the most controversial aspects of orca captivity, was subject to a ban at her own place of work. She was furious. The International Marine Animal Trainersâ Association (Imata), the organization that develops criteria for marine animal training, was publicly silent but privately furious, too.
In a recording of an Imata panel posted to YouTube in 2014, an attendee asked the then chair of the public relations and promotion committee, Michael Hunt, what he thought of the movie. He, and everyone else who spoke on the panel, seemed disgusted by it.
âWhat movie did we pay for ⦠Man of Steel?â Hunt said, describing his own filmgoing experience. âAnd we snuck into Blackfish so that way they didnât get our money.â
The crowd, including trainers who had dedicated their lives to working with captive marine mammals, erupted into applause and laughter. And again and again as the panelâs plan emerged: âThis is not about the United States, this is about the whole world. We need some material ⦠to show in other countries in other languages so everybody can see the other side, the real and the true side of this story.â Applause. âBe truthful when youâre on TV⦠Donât get caught in a lie. And tell them you want to do live interviews. Live interviews they canât edit, and they canât make you look stupid.â More applause.
Theyâd found their saving grace: though the trainers played a major role in killer whalesâ captivity, Blackfishdid not paint them as the bad guys. âThat gives us a little bit of an advantage as we craft our message,â Hunt could be heard saying. âAs we move forward, we need to be out there proactively telling our story.â
The marine mammal training industry has been in the midst of an identity crisis ever since.
I never sought McBride out. She appeared organically, on my Instagram feed, years later, doing just what Hunt had urged. It was 2021, and I saw a photo of her pressing her cheek to a killer whaleâs mouth. She had also self-published a memoir and defense of killer whale training, I Still Believe, and soon started hosting a podcast, on which she interviewed former killer whale trainers, while keeping up a YouTube channel, Tiktok account, and blog.
âThe hardest thing about speaking openly and publically [sic] about killer whales? The constant repetition and nitpicking. My words are my own. If they donât serve you? Leave. Itâs that simple,â sheâd written in the post that crossed my feed. âMy first priority has always been standing up for trainers and giving us a voice.â
After two years at Loro Parque, McBride had moved on to a senior killer whale training role at Marineland in southern France, a seemingly blissful time. In a recording of her Marineland show, she beams as two orcas cry out their songs for her, on cue. Later in the show, she blows an orca a kiss, and it responds with a little opening of its mouth back. She described Wikie, an orca there, as her âsoul animalâ.
âSheâs the most interesting being Iâve ever met in my entire life,â she later told me.
But things have changed in the decade since Blackfish. Many trainers feel the added public attention around the killer whale captivity debate has not only destroyed any chances of holding on to their dream jobs, but also made them pariahs. McBride told me that an older trainer she knew had said his job used to function as a pickup line at bars. After Blackfish, it was more likely to get a drink thrown in his face than get him laid. Another former trainer told me she struggled with burnout amid all the public scrutiny; she now works as a deckhand on a boat.
As groups like Imata walk the line between angry trainers and a marine park-going public that is now aware of the captive orcaâs plight, some American and European trainers are traveling further afield for work â often to Asia. Meanwhile, captive orcas remain, well, captive â and in some countries, their numbers might be increasing.
âI feel fortunate to be one of the endangered species myself,â Grey Stafford told me. âA killer whale trainer.â
The 90s were âthe glory daysâ for trainers, Stafford says. Sure, there were anti-captivity folks back then, but âyou could literally just have one spokesperson comment, respond to questions or criticism by detractors, and then it would go away,â he said. âThose days are long gone.â
By 2024, Stafford was still speaking out on behalf of animal trainers as a podcaster. He recently wrapped an episode about SeaWorld Ohio and âwhat we lost when she closed her doorsâ. I asked him what we had lost.
âWe have a generation or two now that, unlike you, have not seen human beings in the water with killer whales,â he said. âAnd that is something precious that has been lost.â
For perspective, Deborah Giles, a killer whale researcher at the University of Washington, says that orca captivity âwould be like putting us [humans] in a bathroom, or something that smallâ.
âThese are not well adapted animals for the environment that weâre forcing them into,â she said.
Though marine scientists â including Giles â stand by the facts in Blackfish, certain discrepancies on the productionâs part laid the groundwork for SeaWorldâs rebuttal. SeaWorld noted that video clips occasionally showed a different orca than the one being discussed in the narration, and that Blackfishrelied on sources whoâd formerly, not concurrently, worked at the park. It said that Blackfish didnât mention how SeaWorld ârescues, rehabilitates and returns to the wild hundreds of wild animals every yearâ and âcommits millions of dollars annually to conservation and scientific researchâ. Blackfishwas âinaccurate and misleadingâ, the park claimed.
None of this denies that Tilikum killed three people, or that killer whales are better suited to life in the wild. âTheir social bonds, which are broken when theyâre taken from their family and put into captivity, is part of the very essence of the species, and yet we break that when we take them away,â Giles said.
Nevertheless, McBride and many of her fans want to return to marine parksâ pre-Blackfish heyday. Parades of heart emojis cascade through the comments below each orca pic McBride posts, and fans write in to share their happy memories of killer whale shows. McBride believes Blackfishwas overly sensational, and that the people who care for orcas daily are the ones most equipped to determine whatâs best for them. Likewise, many of her followers disparage the claims made in Blackfish. âBlackfish ð is ð NOT ð a ð resource ð,â said one commenter.
McBride is far from the only trainer advocating for a return to the pre-Blackfish status quo on social media. Another trainer-run account, @Truth4Toki, lobbied against Tokitaeâs planned release from the Miami Seaquarium to her native waters in the Salish Sea. Like McBrideâs page, Truth4Toki argued that trainers knew better than anti-captivity activists what was best for the animal. Its bio boasts that the group has over 300 collective years of experience working with Tokitae. (Tokitae died in a Miami Seaquarium tank in August after more than 50 years in captivity.)
Part of Staffordâs argument for killer whale captivity is that we wouldnât know as much about the species if weâd never captured them.
âIn terms of the specific skills of working with a killer whale, those skills are going away,â he said. âWhat happens when we lose that human capital, the people who know how to disentangle whales off the coast of California? The people who understand maternal behavior? That is going to die out.â
I asked Giles what she thought about that. She offered that when captive facilities started, âWe didnât know better. We just frankly didnât know how intelligent these whales were.â Now we do.
Reflecting on her first trip to SeaWorld, McBride wrote in her memoir: âLooking back it almost seems as if I started out in my career at exactly the wrong time.â
Stafford, however, doesnât believe the dream of training in a pre-Blackfish world is dead. âHereâs the truly ironic thing,â he said. âThe best killer whale training thatâs happening right now is in east Asia.â
Moving to China was never Steve Hearnâs plan. But when a Chinese property developer approached the marine mammal trainer in 2018 about a job opportunity on the island province of Hainan, he was open minded. Hearn, a 30-year industry veteran, was working at a dolphinarium in the Netherlands, where he had âalways worked under a certain amount of activist pressureâ. But, he said, âthe last 10, 15 years has been a lot worse.â
R&F Propertiesâ vision for Hainan Ocean Paradise impressed Hearn; he visited the site as it was under construction and marveled at the size of the holes in the ground. He was offered a position overseeing more than 100 mostly Chinese trainers and began teaching them how to work with marine animals according to Imata standards. The park was also the mainlandâs first to publicly eschew the controversial practice of wild capture, displaying only animals that had been rescued, says Hearn (though animals that had been previously wild-captured by other parties could still count as rescues). It did not house orcas.
That level of regard for the animalsâ provenance and care is rare among the Chinese facilities that do house the animals, according to Taison Chang, chairman of the Hong Kong Dolphin Conservation Society.
Pre-Covid, Chang made a trip to visit some facilities on the mainland, including Chimelong, the self-proclaimed âOrlando of Chinaâ. The $2bn Chimelong Ocean Kingdom, which opened the year after Blackfish premiered, housed nine wild-caught orcas, and in 2017, it celebrated becoming Chinaâs first orca breeding facility. The China Cetacean Alliance (CCA) estimated that, as of 2019, there were 80 ocean parks in China, the majority of which held whales or dolphins in captivity, and another 27 were under construction.
âI was very convinced that the condition of the facilities was poor,â Chang said of the parks he visited. Tanks were sometimes small and poorly maintained, the animals living too densely together. In some instances, species from wildly different habitats shared the same tank.
Chang said the number of marine animal facilities in China would hit 100 soon. China, however, is new to marine park development. And none of this development would have been possible without the help of trainers and marine park experts from the west.
âThere has been a trend that facilities, especially the big ones like Chimelong and Haichang [Ocean Park, in Shanghai], are hiring trainers from the west. They are often portrayed as the âstarâ trainers,â Chang said. This echoed Hearnâs experience at events for Hainan Ocean Paradise: âI had to be there because it was a foreign face showing that weâre investing correctly in all of our aspects of our park.â
That might be due to Chinaâs poor reputation for marine animal welfare. As of 2019, CCA was aware of at least 15 orcas held in captivity in China (the US has 18, all of them at SeaWorld parks), and 14 Chinese parks claimed to have bred marine mammals in captivity. Of the 37 whale or dolphin births CCA was aware of, at least seven of the calves died. The last calf to be born under SeaWorldâs breeding program died in 2017, a year after SeaWorld announced plans to end captive orca breeding.
As SeaWorld struggled to rebrand itself post-Blackfish, Chinaâs Zhonghong Group acquired a 21% stake in SeaWorld Entertainment Inc, making it the largest shareholder, with SeaWorld agreeing to advise the group on future parks abroad. (It terminated the agreement two years later when Zhonghong defaulted on a loan.)
Hearn, though not affiliated with SeaWorld, confirmed the demand in China for western marine park expertise: When I spoke to him in February, he was planning on traveling to Shanghai to consult on three additional marine parks.
When I asked Chang if he saw killer whale captivity continuing to grow in China, he said: âDefinitely.â
Killer whales have not always been an entertainment commodity. A hundred years ago, they were more likely to be cast as monsters than have their likenesses made into stuffed animals.
The change, the historian Jason Colby argues in his book Orca, came mid-century, when industry in the Pacific north-west shifted from reliance on extractive, labor-intensive jobs to a middle-class leisure economy. Orcas were no longer seen as a daily threat to fishermen. Instead, they were marvels â to the white majority of the region, anyway; members of the Lummi Nation say they have always seen orcas as their relatives. The first wild captures for captivity occurred in this region. Like elephants before them, orcas soon became a âmarqueeâ animal, solidifying a certain parkâs status and drawing more spectators.
Paradoxically, Americansâ heightened awareness of killer whales led to greater conservation efforts, which in turn paved the way for todayâs anti-captivity movement. (One subspecies of orca, the Southern Resident orca, remains endangered today.)
Colby tells me heâs fascinated by the number of people heâs met whose transformative encounters with orcas in captivity as children, despite being positive, were the launching pad for anti-captivity activism. I tell him about a reverse scenario: that Iâd spoken to a killer whale trainer who was first inspired by Free Willy, a movie about releasing a whale into the wild. âThat movie doesnât even work if you donât have captive orcas,â he pointed out.
I asked everyone I spoke to what drew them to the oceanâs fiercest predator. Stafford called swimming with orcas âa thrill that I will never enjoy again in my lifeâ. Several people pointed out that orcas are black and white, which, if you think about it, is pretty cool. Others talked about having early visions of orcas as if theyâd been Inception-ed into their brains.
Giles recalled a vivid dream sheâd had as a child, in which she changed places with an orca stuck in a pool. There was no reason for orcas to feature so prevalently in her psyche; she grew up on a worm farm.
A former SeaWorld trainer, Kyle Kittleson, told me: âI was born this way.
âI was born a man. I was born gay. And I was born with a love of marine mammals.â
Like McBride, Kittleson spent years in his landlocked hometown scheming ways to get marine animal experience. When he finally landed the interview at SeaWorld Orlando and traveled to Florida, it had to be rescheduled; it was the day Tilikum killed Dawn Brancheau.
Maybe itâs just that lifelong dreams are hard to shake, but even Brancheauâs death didnât phase Kittleson. He eventually worked in the same stadium she had, loving the crazy-intense swim test he had to pass to even be considered, the parrots he fed and bonded with, the jacket that said âSeaWorldâ on it.
But things were different after Brancheau died. More government regulation creeped into Kittlesonâs work, and he disagreed with the new rules. And then came Blackfish â âa piece of propaganda that was meant to evoke feelings rather than logic from the viewerâ, he claimed â and public opinion shifted underneath him.
Kittleson eventually quit the profession but continued to defend killer whale training online and self-published a guidebook for aspiring trainers, Wear a Wetsuit at Work. Today, though, heâs one of several trainers I spoke to who has pivoted almost entirely away from the field. Kittleson currently runs the educational YouTube page Baba Blast! for kids. He likes his work, even if itâs not what he spent his childhood dreaming about.
Imata, meanwhile, continues to quietly defend its own existence. Throughout the 2010s, its annual conference featured pro-captivity speakers like the former trainer Mark Simmons, the pro-SeaWorld voice in Blackfish. More recently, Imata leader Hunt joined Stafford on his podcast in honor of the organizationâs 50th anniversary, in 2022. (Hunt could not be reached for comment.) This month, Imataâs annual conference featured a behind-the-scenes tour of SeaWorld San Antonio, home to five killer whales.
McBride, too, made a career pivot. In September 2020, she released a YouTube video announcing plans to leave her job at Marineland to be closer to her boyfriend during the pandemic. It was titled The Hardest Decision of My Life.
âIf you are an aspiring trainer out there, I want to let you know that your identity outside of the job is also very important,â McBride said, tearfully, into the camera. âAt the end of the day, sometimes it is just a job.â
These days, sheâs still posting in support of orca captivity. But her new job, social media manager for a non-profit in the Netherlands, really is just a job.
Sounds of the natural world are rapidly falling silent and will become âacoustic fossilsâ without urgent action to halt environmental destruction, international experts have warned.
As technology develops, sound has become an increasingly important way of measuring the health and biodiversity of ecosystems: our forests, soils and oceans all produce their own acoustic signatures. Scientists who use ecoacoustics to measure habitats and species say that quiet is falling across thousands of habitats, as the planet witnesses extraordinary losses in the density and variety of species. Disappearing or losing volume along with them are many familiar sounds: the morning calls of birds, rustle of mammals through undergrowth and summer hum of insects.
Today, tuning into some ecosystems reveals a âdeathly silenceâ, said Prof Steve Simpson from the University of Bristol. âIt is that race against time â weâve only just discovered that they make such sounds, and yet we hear the sound disappearing.â
âThe changes are profound. And they are happening everywhere,â said US soundscape recordist Bernie Krause, who has taken more than 5,000 hours of recordings from seven continents over the past 55 years. He estimates that 70% of his archive is from habitats that no longer exist.
Prof Bryan Pijanowski from Purdue University in the US has been listening to natural sounds for 40 years and taken recordings from virtually all of the worldâs main types of ecosystems.
He said: âThe sounds of the past that have been recorded and saved represent the sounds of species that might no longer be here â so thatâs all weâve got. The recordings that many of us have [are] of places that no longer exist, and we donât even know what those species are. In that sense they are already acoustic fossils.â
Numerous studies are now documenting how natural soundscapes are changing, being disrupted and falling silent. A 2021 study in the journal Nature of 200,000 sites across North America and Europe found âpervasive loss of acoustic diversity and intensity of soundscapes across both continents over the past 25 years, driven by changes in species richness and abundanceâ. The authors added: âOne of the fundamental pathways through which humans engage with nature is in chronic decline with potentially widespread implications for human health and wellbeing.â
The shift in ecosystem sound is happening in the air, the forests, the soil, and even under the water. During the cold war, the US navy used underwater surveillance systems to track Soviet submarines â and found they struggled to do so near coral reefs due to all the sounds reefs produced. It wasnât until 1990 that civilian scientists could listen to this classified data.
âWhenever we went to a healthy reef it blew our minds â the cacophony of sounds we heard,â said Simpson, who has been monitoring coral reefs using hydrophones for more than 20 years. âA healthy reef was a carnival of sound.â
At the outset of his research, noise pollution from motorboats was his main concern, but 2015 and 2016 brought significant bleaching events, which resulted in 80% mortality of corals. âThey cooked the reef,â he said. More than half of the worldâs coral reef cover has now been lost since 1950. If global heating reaches 2C, more than 99% of coral reefs are expected to start dying.
The result of these bleaching events is a âdeathly silenceâ, said Simpson. âWe swam around those reefs crying into our masks.â
âThese sounds and silences speak back to us like in a mirror,â said Hildegard Westerkamp, a Canadian sound ecologist who has been recording soundscapes for half a century, during which time wildlife populations have experienced average declines of almost 70%.
She started working on the World Soundscape Project in 1973 with the intention of documenting disappearing ecosystems. âWe proposed to start to listen to the soundscape, to everything, no matter how uncomfortable it may be â how uncomfortable the message.â
She said: âThe act of listening itself can be both comforting and highly unsettling. But most importantly it tends to connect us to the reality of what we are facing.â
Sound data is now being used alongside visual data as a way to monitor conservation efforts and ecosystem health. More sophisticated and cheaper recording equipment â as well as increasing concerns about environmental destruction â are driving the boom in ecoacoustic monitoring.
As the sophistication of microphones has increased, scientists are using them to monitor life that would not usually be audible to human ears. Marcus Maeder, an acoustic ecologist and sound artist from Switzerland, has been investigating the noises trees make under stress, pushing a microphone into the bark of a tree to listen to the living tissue. Stress sounds like pulses come from within the cavity, he said.
When he first pushed a microphone into the soil of a mountain meadow he discovered it was also alive with noise, âa completely new kingdom of soundsâ.
Intensively managed agricultural land, often doused with pesticides, sounds very different, Maeder said: âThe soil becomes quiet.â
For many researchers, disappearing soundscapes are a source of grief as well as of scientific interest. âItâs a sad thing to be doing, but itâs also helping me tell a story about the beauty of nature,â said Pijanowski. âAs a scientist I have trouble explaining what biodiversity is, but if I play a recording and say what Iâm talking about â these are the voices of this place. We can either work to preserve it or not.
âSound is the most powerful trigger of emotions for humans. Acoustic memories are very strong too. Iâm thinking about it as a scientist, but itâs hard not to be emotional.â
Find more age of extinction coverage here, and follow biodiversity reporters Phoebe Weston and Patrick Greenfield on X for all the latest news and features
The tale starts 30 years ago, when Bernie Krause made his first audio clip in Sugarloaf Ridge state park, 20 minutes’ drive from his house near San Francisco. He chose a spot near an old bigleaf maple. Many people loved this place: there was a creek and a scattering of picnic benches nearby.
As a soundscape recordist, Krause had travelled around the world listening to the planet. But in 1993 he turned his attention to what was happening on his doorstep. In his first recording, a stream of chortles, peeps and squeaks erupt from the animals that lived in the rich, scrubby habitat. His sensitive microphones captured the sounds of the creek, creatures rustling through undergrowth, and the songs of the spotted towhee, orange-crowned warbler, house wren and mourning dove.
Back then, Krause never thought of this as a form of data-gathering. He began recording ecosystem sounds simply because he found them beautiful and relaxing. Krause has ADHD and found no medication would work: “The only thing that relieved the anxiety was being out there and just listening to the soundscapes,” he says.
Inadvertently, he had begun to gather a rich trove of data. Over the next three decades he would return each April to the spot at the bigleaf maple, set his recorder down and wait to hear what it would reveal.
But in April last year, Krause played back his recording and was greeted with something he had not heard before: total silence. The recorder had run for its usual hour, but picked up no birdsong, no rush of water over stones, no beating wings. “I’ve got an hour of material with nothing, at the high point of spring,” says Krause. “What’s happening here is just a small indication of what’s happening almost everywhere on an even larger scale.”
A rich weave of sound fades
Animals produce a vast array of sounds: to find mates, protect territories, identify offspring or simply by moving about. But traditionally, ecologists have measured environmental health by looking at habitats rather than listening to them. Krause developed the idea that the sound of healthy ecosystems contained not only the calls of individual animals, but a dense, structured weave of sounds that he called the “biophony”.
In 2009, when Krause listened through his archive, he realised a story was emerging: a subtle but noticeable loss in the density and variety of natural sounds.
At the same time, he began observing odd things happening in Sugarloaf Ridge park. Leaves on some tree species were unfurling two weeks earlier than documented in historical records. The change in bloom meant migrating birds following the Pacific Flyway were out of sync with sources of food along their route. Winter rain patterns had changed. Then in 2012, exceptional drought conditions started. California had been getting little rain and record hot temperatures, which pushed the parched land into unprecedented territory.
By 2014, northern California was experiencing its most serious drought in 1,200 years, and the bird song in Krause’s recording becomes muted.
In 2015, the quiet sets in. There is no stream flow or wind in the audio. In 2016, the hush is broken only by the call of a purple finch.
“A great silence is spreading over the natural world even as the sound of man is becoming deafening,” Krause wrote in 2012, in his book The Great Animal Orchestra. “The sense of desolation extends beyond mere silence.”
Life swept away by fire
Then, in 2017, the Tubbs fire struck, the most destructive wildfire in northern California’s modern history.
Krause happened to be awake at 2.30am on the October morning when the flames reached his home. He and his wife had to run through a wall of fire surrounding the house. “Except for us, not one single item that we had amassed over the arc of our lives survived,” he says. “As we raced toward the car, a fire tornado seethed with a voice of rage.
“That sound haunts us to this day,” he says. “I rarely make it through a night without awakening to frightful sonic nightmares.”
Propelled by gusts of 78mph, the fire incinerated entire neighbourhoods. Krause’s cats, Seaweed and Barnacle, died. He lost 70 years of letters, photographs and field journals, in flames so intense they left the refrigerator an unrecognisable puddle of aluminium and steel. His precious recording archive survived, in copies stored elsewhere.
The Tubbs fire burned 80% of Sugarloaf Ridge park. John Roney, the park manager, managed to evacuate 50-60 campers as the fire roared towards them.
The bigleaf maple survived. It stood up to the fire,” says Breck Parkman, a retired state parks archaeologist. “It lost branches and got partially stunted, but it survived.” But in September 2020, the Glass fire hit: one of nearly 30 wildfires across California that month.
“That pretty much finished off what was left of that tree,” says Parkman. He remembers once taking Clint Eastwood to look at it, as well as some botanists trying to establish if it was the biggest maple in the American west – they never confirmed its status. “It didn’t really matter, though. The birds knew the tree was grand. For them, this was the tree of life,” he says.
He believes the tree should have lived for a few hundred more years and likens it to an elder at family gatherings who brings wonderful food. One day that person disappears. “It’s a type of sadness – it’s hard to describe,” he says.
“It’s a loss, and there’s a longing. I would suspect the birds still miss that tree. I do.”
Many forest ecosystems are reliant on fire to decompose dead wood and old leaves but historically these tended to be smaller fires. They did not typically burn the tree canopy, so insects and other animals could take refuge without getting scorched. The larger fires in recent years are much hotter and threaten endangered species that have restricted ranges.
Desirae Harp, an educator at the state park and member of the local Mishewal Wappo tribe, says the silence that fell after the fires broke her heart.
“Hearing that silence, of all those native plants and animals, is heartbreaking because those are our relatives. I feel like when human beings die we call it genocide. But when we destroy whole ecosystems, we don’t always understand the weight of that.”
A silent message to the world
One of the most significant environmental books of the 20th century is Silent Spring by Rachel Carson. Published in 1962, it warned that if people did not stop their destruction of nature, especially through the use of pesticides such as DDT, the number of birds and other wild creatures would continue to decline and silence would begin to fall over the natural world.
In Krause’s recording from April 2023, not only is the birdsong missing, but there is no water in the creek either. “We’re watching this in our own lifetime, which is startling,” he says.
Comparison of 2003 and 2023:
In 2019, Krause argued that the climate crisis could be “changing the Earth’s natural acoustic fabric”. He drew an analogy between the natural world and a concert hall: if the heat and moisture of the concert hall changed, so too would the players’ ability to perform.
“The same is happening for Earth’s orchestra. New atmospheric conditions are detuning natural sounds,” he wrote. “Only major mitigation actions will help preserve Earth’s beat.”
One of the reasons people were first drawn to Sonoma county, where most of the state park lies, was to go fishing, hunting and swim in the creeks. In the 1970s there were many places to swim, says Steven Lee, a research manager at Sonoma Ecology Center. “People don’t swim in the creeks here any more. Why not? Because there’s not enough water.”
The biodiversity associated with the streams has also been lost. Chinook salmon and steelhead trout are unable to reach their spawning grounds if there is no water. “It’s definitely drastic,” says Lee, about Krause’s latest recording. “The pessimist in me would say that we’re probably going to see a lot of these declines continue to happen.”
Waterways are critical lifelines for wildlife in dry places such as California, with a whole cascade of life depending on them. Droughts mean this lifeblood no longer flows through the landscape.
Caitlin Cornwall, a project manager at the Sonoma Ecology Center, says: “There is a direct link between reversing climate change and having more birds in Bernie’s recordings.
She calls Sugarloaf “a relatively mid-range example of what happens when you have an extreme drought”.
The drought is not the only pressure. Across the state, human activity is cutting into animal food sources and habitats. Wild places are being converted into farmland and urban areas, and invasive species are becoming more common. Some of the songbirds Krause captured in 1993, such as the orange-crowned warbler, are now in widespread decline.
Many of the birds captured in Krause’s recordings are migrant species “living on a knife-edge”, says Cornwall. “If a year’s cohorts have died in a particular place, then next year the young – and even the adults – might not come back.” It could take generations for them to recolonise a habitat – assuming they survive elsewhere.
Krause, who has been recording ecosystems from Africa to Latin America to Europe, says it is depressing to hear how the places he visits have changed. His personal library contains more than 5,000 hours of recordings, taken over 55 years from all over the world. He estimates that 70% of his archive is from habitats that have now disappeared.
“The changes are profound,” he says. “And they are happening everywhere.”
“I’ve got to this point in my life now where I just don’t know quite how to handle it, or how to express it, or what to say – yet I’ve got to tell people what I see and what I hear. Actually, I don’t need to say anything – the messages are revealed through the soundscapes.”
There have been some optimistic signs at Sugarloaf Ridge. Roney has 40 cameras around the park, which have taken 60,000 photos in the past five years. He says there are hopeful indications, such as black bears and mountain lions moving into the area. Krause is 85 now and says his hearing days are numbered: he is almost totally deaf in his right ear and has some hearing loss in his left. He can no longer hear subtle changes in sound like he used to. “That’s a loss that I quite regret but have learned to live with,” he says.
Still, he looks forward to spring and to his next recording in Sugarloaf Ridge. He is hopeful that this year there could be signs of a resurgence. “The stories conveyed through the voices of these critters will tell us all we need to know that’s worthwhile,” he says. “When we finally learn how to listen.”
Find more age of extinction coverage here, and follow biodiversity reporters Phoebe Weston and Patrick Greenfield on X for all the latest news and features
The UK faces food shortages and price rises as extreme weather linked to climate breakdown causes low yields on farms locally and abroad.
Record rainfall has meant farmers in many parts of the UK have been unable to plant crops such as potatoes, wheat and vegetables during the key spring season. Crops that have been planted are of poor quality, with some rotting in the ground.
The persistent wet weather has also meant a high mortality rate for lambs on the UK’s hills, while some dairy cows have been unable to be turned out on to grass, meaning they will produce less milk.
Agricultural groups have said the UK will be more reliant on imports, but similarly wet conditions in European countries such as France and Germany, as well as drought in Morocco, could mean there is less food to import. Economists have warned this could cause food inflation to rise, meaning higher prices at supermarkets.
Tom Bradshaw, the president of the National Farmers’ Union, said markets had “collapsed” as farmers fail to produce food in the punishing conditions. He said: “We’re going to be importing a lot more product this year.”
One major retailer said the wholesale price of potatoes was up 60% year on year as much of the crop had rotted in the ground.
Supplies of potatoes have also been affected by a 10% reduction in the area planted last year as farmers switched to less weather dependent and more financially secure crops. Industry insiders said they expected a further 5% fall in planting this year.
Jack Ward, chief executive of the British Growers Association, said: “There is a concern that we won’t ever have the volumes [of potatoes] we had in the past in the future.”
He said wholesale prices were too low for farmers to generate enough income to cope with high fuel, labour and machinery costs as well as the effects of climate breakdown. “We are not in a good position and it is 100% not sustainable.”
Supplies of carrots and parsnips, which are left in the ground and so also affected by sodden soils, are also much lower than usual, pushing up prices.
Martin Lines, the chief executive of Nature Friendly Farming Network, said: “The impact in the UK this year will significantly affect potatoes and the salad crop. Farmers are already facing delays in planting, with many fields in poor condition. If planting occurs at all, it will likely be late, potentially leading to a shortage of root vegetables and potatoes this coming winter.
“Some farmers have ceased planning for planting altogether, opting instead to put fields into fallow or switch to alternative crops. This could also result in shortages of wheat, barley and pulses as it’s currently unprofitable to grow these due to the lateness of the season and low forecasted prices.”
Guy Singh-Watson, the founder of the organic vegetable box company Riverford, said he had so far planted “virtually no veg”. “Some overgrown plants cannot wait any longer to go in the ground, and will have to be ditched.”
While retailers often turn to imports to fill gaps on shelves, farmers across Europe are enduring a similarly difficult start to the year, with difficulties developing winter crops and sowing spring crops.
France is experiencing the poorest start to its wheat-growing season since 2020 amid cold wet weather, while production of fruit and vegetables in Morocco is being affected by drought. Morocco’s second-largest reservoir has dried up, meaning irrigating crops will be difficult.
Amber Sawyer, an analyst at the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit, said last year almost a third of the UK’s tomatoes, and more than two-thirds of its raspberries and brussels sprouts, came from Morocco.
“As climate change worsens, the threat to our food supply chains – both at home and overseas – will grow,” Sawyer said.
Scientists have said this is just the beginning of shocks to the food supply chain caused by climate breakdown and that without rapid action to drive down emissions by ceasing to burn fossil fuels, the current system is unsustainable.
Dr Paul Behrens, an associate professor of environmental change at Leiden University in the Netherlands, said: “We should all be extremely concerned. We need to be doing everything to reduce emissions while transforming our food systems.”
He added: “If we don’t … I expect huge turmoil and escalating prices in the next 10 to 20 years. When food prices spiral we always expect political instability. I wish people understood the urgent climate threat to our near-term food security.
“Fortunately, we know many ways we can make the food system more resilient while reducing food emissions. The biggest opportunity in high-income nations is a reduction in meat consumption and exploration of more plants in our diets.”
The yew in the churchyard here has a legend as the oldest tree in Britain, although its exact age is a matter of dispute. Many propose that it is older than Christianity and some that it could even predate Stonehenge.
Perhaps a more revealing comparison arises with an “artefact” from about the same period (circa 3000BC). It’s the man called “Oetzi”, whose leathery, ice-preserved remains were extracted from a Tirolean glacier in 1991, along with his deerskin boots and bearskin cap. Oetzi carried a mark of high prestige in his little copper axe, but this state-of-the-art technology also had a handle made of the same wood as the tree in Fortingall. The Scottish yew has thus endured from the age of copper to a time when children (like those standing next to us as we visited) take Snapchat shots on smartphones.
The tree, in truth, is much reduced since 1769, when it was lassoed by Daines Barrington and measured at 15.9 metres. Souvenir hunters began hacking off parts of its monumental girth until concerned locals threw up a wall – some see it as a prison – to protect the remains. As I pondered my tree, I wondered how best to capture its full eldritch condition.
Should I photograph the blackening heartwood, some of whose laminar swirling shapes suggest the eddying surface to a pollen-stained river, but also the flames licking up from a wood fire? Or does its true exceptionalism lie in the cone-like flowers that are still sprouting at the twig ends and, at this very moment, look for all the world like any rain-sodden greenery in this landscape?
My dilemma reminded me of a pronouncement by the Greek philosopher Heraclitus, known for a series of fragmentary sayings, many paradoxical in nature. Life, he proposed, was akin to music produced when the strings of a bow are laid crosswise upon a lyre. Harmony arises in the tension of these diametrically opposed strings. “The name of the bow is life,” he wrote, “and its work [the music] is death.” The Fortingall yew, which is closer to immortality than any other resident in these islands, is perhaps the most death-like life I’ve ever seen.
Intense thunderstorms are forecast across parts of the Gulf on Monday and Tuesday, bringing very high rainfall to the region and a significant flooding risk in parts.
Low pressure over the Arabian peninsula will deepen on Monday while a flow of moist tropical air moves into the region, significantly enhancing the production of showers as a result.
Shower activity will increase through Monday with the development of a line of severe thunderstorms to the east of Riyadh, the capital of Saudi Arabia, which will push onwards into southern parts of the United Arab Emirates. Heavy downpours are expected, with some places expected to get up to 40mm of rain within three hours, alongside outbreaks of hail. Blustery conditions are also anticipated, with the risk of dust storms that could hinder visibility.
Widespread thunderstorms will continue to develop within the Gulf overnight, pushing farther north into the UAE and dominating the forecast throughout Tuesday. By the time thunderstorms ease on Tuesday evening, about 40mm of rain is expected to have fallen widely across northern parts of the UAE within 24 hours, with more than 100mm possible for the northernmost tip of the country.
Dubai, which typically receives about 7mm on average for the entire month of April, may get up to 100mm, with even higher totals possible.
Much of Europe has been undergoing exceptionally mild conditions for the time of year, with a multitude of records broken in Spain and France over the weekend. Temperatures in northern parts of Spain were akin to those usually experienced in summer, with highs in the 30s celsius. The maximum temperature recorded was 33.5C on Saturday at Miranda de Ebro in Castilla y Leon.
Meanwhile, more than 150 maximum monthly temperature records were broken on the same day in France, with a peak of 32.4C at Sabres. However, this is soon to change, with much cooler conditions forecast this week across much of Europe, bringing the potential for overnight frost.
Finally, it has been confirmed that March 2024 was the warmest on record globally. This is also the 10th consecutive month that has broken the average global temperature record for that month. While the heat can be linked to El Niño’s ongoing phase in the Pacific Ocean, climate scientists are concerned that records may continue to fall, even as El Niño tapers off in the coming months.
France has been accused of hypocrisy by conservationists over a fresh post-Brexit dispute with the UK over fishing rights.
France launched an official protest after the UK banned bottom trawling from parts of its territorial waters last month, with the aim of protecting vulnerable habitats.
The ban on bottom trawling â a hugely damaging fishing technique that drags heavy nets along the seabed â covers British as well as EU vessels, and applies to 13 marine protected areas (MPAs), covering 4,000 sq km.
French diplomats claimed the move breached the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA), which could lead to punitive measures against the UK if an arbitration tribunal rules in Franceâs favour.
Charles Clover, director of the Blue Marine Foundation, a UK-based conservation organisation,said the TCA clearly permitted fishing restrictions provided they were applied equally.
âThis is hypocrisy by the French,â he said. âThey are not looking at the small print.
âThey are playing a ludicrous ideological game against their own rightwing parties, grabbing back support from the trawlermen and not looking at what the rules are.â
The Paris-based environmental group Bloom said it would consider legal action against France if it continued the dispute.
Claire Nouvian, head of Bloom, said the French president, Emmanuel Macron, was showing the world his true ideological stripes.
âIt is an embarrassment for France, who say they are champions of the worldâs oceans, to do this,â she said.
âIt highlights the discrepancy between their words and their actions. If they keep going down that route, we will look into litigation ourselves to sue the French government.â
Many trawlers operating out of Boulogne depend on the restricted areas for much of their catch. Far-right politicians have backed the trawler operators, with Rassemblement National, the parliamentary party led by Marine Le Pen, stepping up rhetoric on the issue.
Last year, an editorial in Nature magazine described France â which held a global oceans summit in 2022 and is hosting next yearâs UN ocean conference â as being among the countries undermining progress towards ocean sustainability because it opposed a ban on bottom trawling in marine protected areas in the EU.
In 2022, France, the UK and Costa Rica launched the High Ambition Coalition for Nature & People to push for protecting 30% of land and sea by 2030 (known as the â30×30â target).
Nouvian said: âThe TCA language is precise. Itâs not discrimination to implement what the scientists have been saying and what member states have been talking about in their 30×30 plans.â
She noted that all member states were expected to ban bottom trawling in MPAs by 2030 under the EUâs ocean action plans.
A UK government spokesperson said: âWe are proud of our strong record of safeguarding our oceans and the precious species that depend on them. The recent decision to prohibit bottom trawling, which applies to all vessels âincluding British ones â followed extensive consultation with a range of stakeholders, including UK and French fishing organisations.
âIt represents a significant step in protecting our vulnerable and ecologically valuable rock and reef habitats, where the scientific evidence has demonstrated the negative impact of bottom-towed fishing gear.â
Officials from the European Commission were meeting their French and UK counterparts on Monday to discuss the issue.
A commission spokesperson said: âWe are having a meeting to share information on adopted, or about to be adopted, measures, as part of our technical exchanges.â
It is the second dispute this year over the UKâs marine conservation measures. In February, Denmark and Sweden asked the EU to intervene after the UK closed part of the Dogger Bank fishing grounds in the North Sea to protect seabirds.
A climate-disrupted ocean is pushing sharks, rays and other species to flee ever-hotter water in the tropics, only for them to be killed by increasingly intense upwells of cold water from the depths, a study has found.
One of the authors of the paper described the “eerie” aftermath of a mass die-off of more than 260 marine organisms from 81 species in a singular event of extreme cold upwelling off the coast of South Africa in 2021.
The paper, published in Nature Climate Change on Monday, found that shifts in ocean currents and pressure systems driven by climate breakdown were increasing the frequency and intensity of upwellings, which may in turn increase the vulnerability of migratory species such as bull sharks.
Scientists focused on the mass die-off event in 2021, which they were able to track in unusually precise detail because one of affected creature that survived was a bull shark that had been satellite tagged. They found it had been caught in water that fell more than 10C below the temperature that such tropical species were used to.
The paper details how the shark changed its behaviour in an attempt to avoid the cold areas. It swam much closer to the surface than normal and moved outside its normal migration pattern.
Many of the affected sea creatures’ carcasses washed up on the shore of South Africa, including the pup of a big manta ray that had been aborted by its traumatised mother.
“It was eerie to see so many species washed up dead,” said Ryan Daly, one of the authors of the paper. He said he was surprised that even the very mobile species, such as manta rays and bull sharks, were caught in the upwelling. “You’d think they would have swum away but they got squeezed. They couldn’t escape,” he said.
To understand the broader trends behind the die-off, the scientists tagged other sharks and used 41 years of sea surface temperature data and 33 years of wind records to investigate the frequency and intensity of cold “killer events” inshore of the Indian Ocean’s Agulhas current and the east Australian current in the past 30 years.
They found cold upwelling events had increased in frequency and intensity in these regions between 1981 and 2022. Other species killed in such events include whale sharks, convict surgeonfish, bigeye trevallies and common blacktip sharks.
Tagged bull sharks appeared to change their behaviour to avoid sudden temperature drops by swimming closer to the surface, sheltering in bays and estuaries and only moving to the extent of their poleward distribution during warm seasons.
The marine biologists worked with oceanographers to map upwelling trends and forecast what could happen in the future as climate disruption becomes ever more pronounced and extreme cold upwellings increase in frequency along with periods of extreme surface heat.
Within individual species, certain groups tend to live on the edge of their population range. Daly said these groups were most vulnerable to the sudden and protracted temperature shifts. “There are bull sharks that run the gauntlet of a cool area to get to thermal refuges. Upwellings could kill off this unique genetic diversity.”
He said the findings suggested the need for a new approach to marine conservation that incorporated knowledge about the increasingly complex ways that climate chaos is affecting marine species. “We need to think about expanding conservation areas and prioritising different species,” he said. “We need to think out of the box.”
Global heating has pushed the world’s coral reefs to a fourth planet-wide mass bleaching event that is on track to be the most extensive on record, US government scientists have confirmed.
Some 54% of ocean waters containing coral reefs have experienced heat stress high enough to cause bleaching, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s Coral Reef Watch said.
A global bleaching event is declared when at least 12% of corals in each of the main ocean basins – Pacific, Atlantic and Indian – experience bleaching-level heat stress within a 12-month period. The declaration also requires confirmed reports of bleaching.
Coral Reef Watch also confirmed the world’s largest coral reef system – Australia’s Great Barrier Reef – had been through its most widespread heat stress event on record in 2024.
The first global bleaching event happened in 1998 with 20% of the ocean’s reef corals exposed to a level of heat stress high enough to cause bleaching. The second event, in 2010, saw 35% reaching that threshold, and the third from 2014 to 2017 peaked at 56%.
Dr Derek Manzello, the Coral Reef Watch director, told the Guardian the current bleaching was likely to surpass the previous most widespread event soon “because the percentage of reef areas experiencing bleaching-level heat stress has been increasing by roughly 1% per week”.
NOAA’s threshold for the onset of bleaching relates to the amount of accumulated heat corals are facing at any given time, known as degree heating weeks.
For example, a 1 DHW is accumulated if corals are subjected to temperatures 1C above the usual maximum for seven days. Coral Reef Watch considers 4 DHWs as a bleaching threshold.
Coral reefs are rich in biodiversity and provide habitat to a quarter of all marine species while covering less than 1% of ocean area. Reefs provide food and tourism income to millions of people and protect coastlines, but are considered to be one of the most vulnerable ecosystems to global heating.
The current global event started in early 2023 and in the northern hemisphere summer reefs across the Americas bleached from record levels of heat stress.
Mass bleaching has been confirmed throughout the tropics, NOAA said, including Florida, the Caribbean, Brazil, many countries across the south Pacific, the Middle East and in parts of the Indian Ocean from Indonesia’s west coast to reefs off east Africa.
Prolonged and severe bleaching can kill corals, but if temperatures fall quickly enough the animals can recover. Research has found previously bleached corals find it harder to reproduce and can be more susceptible to disease after bleaching.
Manzello said global heating had combined with a global El Niño to push up sea surface temperatures. He said predictions made by scientists decades ago about the fate of corals in a warming world were now coming to pass.
“The bottom line is that as coral reefs experience more frequent and severe bleaching events, the time they have to recover is becoming shorter and shorter. Current climate models suggest that every reef on planet Earth will experience severe, annual bleaching sometime between 2040 and 2050.”
Prof Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, a pioneer of coral research who was among the first to link bleaching to global heating, said: “It’s a shock. We clearly have to prevent governments from investing in fossil fuels, or we won’t have a chance in hell [to save reefs].”
Earlier this year, Coral Reef Watch was forced to add three new alert levels to its global coral bleaching warning system to represent ever-increasing extremes.
Prof Tracy Ainsworth, the vice-president of the International Coral Reef Society, said the bleaching had extended to some of the most remote places on Earth.
“Globally we are failing to protect coral reefs and the communities that rely upon them. This is neglect on a global scale,” Ainsworth said.
The Great Barrier Reef is now suffering its fifth mass bleaching in eight years. Coral Reef Watch data shows 80% of the reef was subjected to bleaching-level heat stress in 2024, the highest extent on record and above the previous high of 60% seen in 2017.
Dr Roger Beeden, the chief scientist at the Australian government’s Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority, said it was more important than ever to see global action on climate change.
“But the prognosis is not good for coral reefs as we know them, and the GBR is not immune. We are certainly not giving up on reefs, but they’re under serious pressure.”