‘Days of severe storms’ to rumble across Australia, with hail and millions of lightning strikes expected | Environment

Days of severe storms have been forecast for every mainland state and territory in Australia this week, with possible wind gusts, heavy rain, large hail and flash flooding on the cards.

Weatherzone meteorologist Ben Domensino said “millions of lightning strikes” were also expected across the country.

“We have a number of low pressure troughs sitting over Australia that are interacting with very warm and humid air coming in from the oceans surrounding Australia, which are warmer than average for this time of year,” he said.

In Sydney, temperatures were forecast to remain in the mid-20s for the rest of the week and into the weekend. Melbourne could expect to reach 25C on Tuesday and 20C on Wednesday, warming up towards the weekend with temperatures in the 30s forecast for Saturday and Sunday.

But thunderstorms were forecast to continue across parts of New South Wales, south-east Queensland and central Australia on Tuesday, while northern and Western Australia were set to bear the brunt of low pressure troughs in the latter half of the week.

Dean Narramore, senior meteorologist with the Bureau of Meteorology, said Tasmania was the only state that may escape the wild weather.

“We’re just looking at days of severe storms across parts of the country, and particularly north-east New South Wales and south-east Queensland for the coming days, with Wednesday probably being the bigger day,” he said.

Severe thunderstorms could mean damaging wind gusts and heavy rain with the potential for flash flooding or large hail, he added.

There was also the potential for severe thunderstorms in central Australia – near the border of South Australia, Western Australia and the Northern Territory – with large hail, damaging winds and heavy rainfall likely, he said.

skip past newsletter promotion

Meanwhile, in parts of northern Australia, severe to locally extreme heatwaves with 40C temperatures were forecast for Marble Bar in Western Australia throughout the week, expected to peak at 45C on Wednesday.

“We’ll start to see that ease as we head towards the weekend, at least for the Kimberley and the Top End,” Narramore said, though heatwave conditions were expected to continue around Cape York into the weekend.

The recent State of the Climate report, released by the bureau and CSIRO, said global heating caused by burning fossil fuels was fuelling warmer ocean temperatures and longer, more intense heatwaves.

Continue Reading

Wreck of lost US second world warship known as ‘the dancing mouse’ found | Second world war

The wreck of the long-lost US warship USS Edsall, sent to the bottom of the sea during the second world war by the Japanese, has been discovered, US and Australian officials announced on Monday.

The warship was sunk on 1 March 1942, three months after Japan’s attack on Pearl Harbor. The Edsall was traveling across the Indian Ocean south of Java when it was sunk by Japanese dive bombers.

The Edsall’s formidable display in evading attacks before its demise led the Japanese to dub the ship “the dancing mouse”.

“I am honored to acknowledge the role #AusNavy played in discovering the wreck of @usnavy USS Edsall, a warship that holds a special place in our shared naval histories,” wrote Caroline Kennedy, the US ambassador to Australia, in an Instagram post to commemorate Veterans Day.

“We will now be able to preserve this important memorial and hope that the families of the heroes who died there will know their loved ones rest in peace,” said Kennedy in an accompanying video.

The second world war ship, only about 300ft in length, was carrying 153 sailors and several dozen army air forces pilots and soldiers. It had sustained damage from an earlier attack and deemed unfit for combat but was deployed to aid another ship when it encountered Japanese naval forces at about 4pm.

Despite its damaged state, the Edsall successfully dodged attacks for over an hour, swerving to avoid the hundreds of fired shells. The Edsall counterattacked with a smokescreen and torpedoes before eventually being overcome by Japanese dive bombers.

Historians say that a few people on board survived the sinking ship but were immediately picked up by enemy forces and later beheaded in a prison camp.

According to the US navy, the wreck was first discovered late last year south of Australia’s remote Christmas Island submerged in 18,000ft of water. The US cooperated with Australian officials to confirm the wreck was in fact the Edsall.

Mark Hammond, chief of the Royal Australian Navy, said in the video that the wreck was found by the MV Stoker, an Australian naval support ship that is normally used for hydrographic surveying.

The wreckage was subsequently examined with underwater robots and sonar. The Australian navy has not disclosed what the Stoker was doing when the Edsall was found, citing “operational security sensitivities”, according to the Washington Post.

Continue Reading

Trump picks ally Lee Zeldin as environment chief and vows to roll back rules | Trump administration

Donald Trump has picked Lee Zeldin, a former New York congressman, to lead the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), vowing the appointment will “ensure fair and swift deregulatory decisions” by the regulator.

Trump, who oversaw the rollback of more than 100 environmental rules when he last was US president, said that Zeldin was a “true fighter for America First policies” and that “he will ensure fair and swift deregulatory decisions that will be enacted in a way to unleash the power of American businesses, while at the same time maintaining the highest environmental standards, including the cleanest air and water on the planet”.

Zeldin, a Republican who was in the House of Representatives until last year as a member for a New York district that covers part of Long Island, said the nomination was an “honor” and that he was looking forward to cutting red tape as the EPA administrator.

“We will restore US energy dominance, revitalize our auto industry to bring back American jobs, and make the US the global leader of AI,” Zeldin wrote on X. “We will do so while protecting access to clean air and water.”

Zeldin, 44, is considered a close Trump ally and ran in a surprisingly close race for New York governor in 2022, before being pipped by Kathy Hochul, a Democrat. During the campaign, Zeldin attacked Hochul’s “far-left climate agenda” and assailed Democrats for allegedly forcing people to drive electric cars.

The EPA nominee, who will have to be confirmed by the US Senate, has rarely spoken out on environmental or climate issues, although he said in 2014 he was “not sold yet on the whole argument that we have as serious a problem as other people are” with global heating, and added in 2018 that he did not support the Paris climate agreement, which Trump is again expected to withdraw the US from.

Zeldin, who has a score of just 14% from the League of Conservation Voters on his votes on environmental issues in his 15 years in Congress, is expected to oversee an overhaul of the EPA that will rival anything seen since its foundation in 1970.

An exodus of staff is expected from the agency, with employees already raising fears they will be subject to political interference and that their work to protect Americans from toxic chemicals and planet-heating emissions from cars, trucks and power plants will be torn up.

“Naming an unqualified, anti-American worker who opposes efforts to safeguard our clean air and water lays bare Donald Trump’s intentions to, once again, sell our health, our communities, our jobs, and our future out to corporate polluters,” Ben Jealous, executive director of the Sierra Club, said of Zeldin’s nomination.

“Our lives, our livelihoods, and our collective future cannot afford Lee Zeldin – or anyone who seeks to carry out a mission antithetical to the EPA’s mission.”

The naming of Zeldin, less than a week after Trump won the presidential election, is far quicker than his previous term in the White House, when he took until December to name Scott Pruitt as his pick for the EPA.

Pruitt resigned in 2018 amid a flurry of ethics scandals, including allegations that he gave staffers improper pay raises, that he constructed an expensive soundproof phone booth in his office, and that he tasked employees with fetching him moisturizer and a favorite mattress.

Continue Reading

Keir Starmer to unveil ambitious new UK climate goal at Cop29 | Cop29

Keir Starmer will announce a stringent new climate goal for the UK on Tuesday, the Guardian can reveal, with a target in line with the advice given to the government by its scientists and independent advisers.

The UK will pledge to cut emissions by 81% compared with 1990 levels by 2035, a target in line with the recommendations of the Climate Change Committee.

The goal will be one of the first national plans on cutting carbon, known as “nationally determined contributions” or NDCs in UN jargon, to be unveiled at Cop29, the crucial UN climate summit taking place in Azerbaijan this week, and is expected to be one of the most ambitious of any government at the talks.

The goal would be achieved by decarbonising the power sector and through a massive expansion of offshore wind, as well as through investments in carbon capture and storage and nuclear energy.

The UK is one of the first countries to announce an NDC, which are not due until February next year. Campaigners have found the NDCs submitted so far “underwhelming”. The NDC submitted by the previous Cop host, the United Arab Emirates, was described as “greenwashing” by 350.org. A submission by the next host, Brazil, was also criticised for being insufficient and called “misaligned” by Climate Observatory.

Friends of the Earth’s head of campaigns, Rosie Downes, said: “With the warning signals flashing red, a planet battered by increasingly severe floods, storms and heatwaves, and the election of climate denier President Trump, the need for climate leadership by the UK has never been more urgent. Starmer’s 2035 carbon-reduction pledge is a step in the right direction but must be seen as a floor to the level of ambition, not a ceiling. Deeper, faster cuts are needed to help avert the climate collision course we are on.

“Furthermore, if these targets are to be credible, they must be backed by a clear plan to ensure they are met. The UK’s existing 2030 commitment is currently way off course.”

On Monday, the World Meteorological Organization followed the EU space programme in saying 2024 was on track to become the hottest year on record.

Few big countries have yet come up with NDCs. The Cop29 talks opened on Monday, but will ratchet up a gear on Tuesday when scores of heads of state and government fly in from around the world.

Giorgia Meloni, the prime minister of Italy, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, the president of Turkey and Mohammed bin Salman, the crown prince of Saudi Arabia, are among the other leaders attending. Joe Biden of the US, Xi Jinping of China, Olaf Scholz of Germany and Emmanuel Macron of France will not be at the talks, with the latter two preoccupied by domestic political crises.

On Monday, delegates heard stark warnings from the UN climate chief, Simon Stiell, and the Cop president and Azerbaijani environment minister, Mukhtar Babayev, urging countries to step up with strong commitments on the climate before it is too late.

This summit, at which nearly 200 countries are expected to be represented, will focus on climate finance – ways of getting poor countries access to the money they need to cut their greenhouse gas emissions and adapt to the impacts of extreme weather.

About $1tn (£780bn) is expected to be needed each year by 2035, but developed countries have agreed to ensure only $100bn a year from public funds.

skip past newsletter promotion

The host country claimed an early win in the talks by signing off on a deal intended to make carbon offsets work for the planet, and as a source of cash for poor countries.

Diplomats have given the green light to rules that govern the trade of “carbon credits”, breaking a deadlock that has lasted years and paving the way for rich countries to pay for cheap climate action abroad while delaying expensive emission cuts at home. But critics warned the rules were rushed through without following proper process.

Carbon offsets, or carbon credits, are awarded to countries with large forests that absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, or to projects that reduce greenhouse gas emissions, such as wind or solar farms. Selling them should be a source of cash for the developing world, but years of argument over how exactly such a system would work have prevented the widespread uptake of trading systems.

The beginnings of a potential system for trading were set out in article 6 of the Paris climate agreement in 2015, but countries have struggled to put the idea into practice, owing to disagreements over technical issues, such as how to avoid double counting, and ideological differences, as some countries are wary of using carbon offsets.

Azerbaijan hopes the progress on article 6 will clear the way for more substantive talks, for the rest of the scheduled fortnight, on a goal of making $1tn a year in climate finance available to poorer countries by 2035.

However, many civil society groups remain concerned about article 6. Erika Lennon, an attorney at the Center for International Environmental Law, said: “We’ve seen over and over again how carbon markets are not doing what they claim to be doing, as well as market projects that violate people’s rights. If they don’t have strong rules in place to prevent all of the abuses, it can totally undermine the integrity of the Paris agreement.”

Continue Reading

Critics say approval of ‘climate credits’ rules on day one of Cop29 was rushed | Cop29

Diplomats have greenlit key rules that govern the trade of “carbon credits”, breaking a years-long deadlock and paving the way for rich countries to pay for cheap climate action abroad while delaying expensive emission cuts at home.

The agreement, reached late on the first day of Cop29 in Azerbaijan, was hailed by the hosts as an early win at climate talks that have been snubbed by prominent world leaders and clouded by the threat of a US retreat from climate diplomacy after Donald Trump’s victory in the presidential election.

But critics have warned the rules were rushed through without following proper process.

“We welcome this positive momentum,” said Mukhtar Babayev, the president of Cop29, praising a “spirit of compromise that I hope will inspire all our work here in Baku”.

The rules deal with some of the final hurdles to creating a system in which countries can buy credits for removing or avoiding planet-heating pollution in other parts of the world – for instance, by planting trees or saving rainforests – and count the progress toward their own emissions targets.

The agreement is expected to provide the clarity needed to trade emissions within a global carbon market, supervised by the UN, that would be open to companies as well as countries. A separate article on the trade of carbon credits between individual nations will be addressed later in the Cop29 negotiations.

Carbon markets are a polarising force in climate policy. Supporters say they help direct crucial funds to saving the planet while critics point to the tattered history of fraudulent and harmful projects – particularly in the voluntary carbon market that some companies have enthusiastically embraced – that have eroded trust in the concept and driven calls for stricter rules.

Efforts to agree on carbon market rules – known in Cop jargon as article 6 – have been a persistent stumbling block in UN talks to stop the planet from heating. Diplomats at the last climate talks rejected proposals from a UN supervisory body that was tasked with recommending solutions for countries to debate.

This year, with pressure to make progress on carbon markets riding high, the group took a different approach, and adopted new standards on methods and removals while recommending the Cop29 negotiators give it the green light.

Isa Mulder, a policy expert at the nonprofit group Carbon Market Watch, said that adopting the rules on the first day of the summit without discussion “undermined trust” in the UN climate conference process. “Kicking off Cop29 with a backdoor deal … sets a poor precedent for transparency and proper governance,” she said.

The rules are expected to reduce the risk of double-counting emissions – a big concern of critics – and include stronger safeguards to protect human rights.

But the text also leaves many unanswered questions, said Mulder, such as how to deal with projects whose carbon-saving successes face a risk of reversal.

skip past newsletter promotion

Olga Gassan-zade, a former chair of the article 6 supervisory body and one of its current members, said: “The criticisms of the process are fair – but it was also critically important to operationalise article 6.4 as soon as possible to scale up the delivery of carbon finance to the developing world.”

Critics of carbon markets have pointed to a history of offset projects overpromising and underdelivering, with wildfires burning through forests that were supposed to be protected and emissions from renewable energy projects being counted on balance books even though they would probably have been built anyway.

Erika Lennon, an attorney at the Centre for International Environmental Law, said: “We’ve seen over and over again how carbon markets are not doing what they claim to be doing, as well as market projects that violate people’s rights.

“If they don’t have strong rules in place to prevent all of the abuses, it can totally undermine the integrity of the Paris agreement.”

Continue Reading

LED lights on underside of surfboards may deter great white shark attacks | Sharks

Using LED lighting on the underside of surfboards or kayaks could deter great white shark attacks, new research suggests.

In an Australian-led study using seal-shaped decoys, underside lighting disrupted the ability of great whites to see silhouettes against the sunlight above, reducing the rates at which the sharks followed and attacked the artificial prey. The brighter the lights, the more effective the deterrent was.

The study’s lead author, Dr Laura Ryan of Macquarie University in Sydney, said white sharks seemed to rely on the visual cues of a dark object silhouetted against a lighter background.

“If you flip that to a light object on a dark background, then it doesn’t seem to be something they recognise as prey,” she said.

Ryan’s previous research on great whites suggests that attacks on humans may be a case of mistaken identity. The animal has a far lower visual acuity – the ability to see shapes and details – than humans.

Her work has suggested that juvenile great white sharks, from below, are unlikely to be able to clearly tell seals apart from swimmers or people paddling surfboards.

Other research has shown that sharks are colour-blind or at best have only limited colour perception abilities.

The new study, conducted in Mossel Bay, South Africa, involved towing decoys behind a boat for dozens of hours.

A great white shark breaches to bite a seal decoy in Mossel Bay, South Africa. Photograph: Nathan Hart/Macquarie University

The researchers initially found success by covering the underside of the decoy entirely in lights. “But if you’re actually going to come up with something to protect people, [entirely] covering a surfboard … is just not practical because it’s a huge amount of lighting, which needs a huge amount of battery power,” Ryan said.

The researchers experimented with more sparse lighting options, finding that horizontal stripes of LED lights had a similar deterrent effect. “When you do horizontal stripes, the silhouette [appears] wider than it is long, so it’s less like a seal,” Ryan said.

Longitudinal strips of light, however, were not effective, nor were strobe lights, which gave the sharks momentary glimpses of the decoy silhouette. “Interestingly, just that small glimpse of the entire silhouette was enough for the white sharks to start biting the decoys,” Ryan said.

The scientists towed the seal decoy to encourage the white sharks to breach – one form of hunting involving rapid acceleration to the surface to catch prey. They say more research is required into shark behaviour with static decoys, which would resemble surfers waiting to catch a wave rather than actively paddling.

The team is currently testing a surfboard prototype with fitted lighting. “Surfers can be a little bit fussy with their surfboards,” Ryan said. “As a surfer, I want it to be useable.”

Globally, most shark bites are associated with people surfing or participating in other board sports. Fatal shark bites, though rare, are mostly due to great whites.

The study, published in the journal Current Biology, noted it would be important to test whether lighting was also effective in deterring other species involved in attacks on humans, such as bull sharks and tiger sharks, as these have different predation behaviours.

Continue Reading

Trump 2.0 could make even the most optimistic climate observers cynical – but it’s not the whole story | Adam Morton

You’ve likely already heard the worst-case takes: that a second Trump presidency is a disaster for the climate, and will almost certainly lead to emissions being higher than they otherwise would have been. There’s obvious truth in that. But it’s also true that Trump 2.0 will almost certainly not play out in line with immediate post-election predictions.

We have been here before. As the writer and analyst Ketan Joshi points out, in 2016 it was projected that Trump’s policies would lead to a steep rise in US emissions – a fork in the road at odds with the decline forecast if Hillary Clinton had won.

In reality, the country’s climate-heating pollution over the past eight years has been roughly what was predicted if the Democrats had been in the White House. There have been a bunch of reasons for this.

Most obviously, Trump promised to bring coal power back but failed, spectacularly. Coal-fired generation fell nearly 40% during his first term as investors and markets abandoned it as a viable, affordable energy source. States and cities ramped up climate action in response to Trump’s rise and private capital began to respond to the signal from the landmark 2015 Paris agreement even as the US pulled out of that deal.

Of course, the pandemic also dented emissions once shutdowns kicked in. But the rebound as the economy reopened did not take US emissions back to where they were before. The most recent data has it slightly below the 2016 projection of life under a Clinton presidency.

Looking ahead, there are a few things we can say.

Trump will again withdraw the US from the Paris agreement, and possibly the overarching UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. At least some of the extraordinary US$370bn (A$560bn) clean energy support in the Inflation Reduction Act is quite likely to be rolled back even though it is driving investment in Republican states – logic is not necessarily a winner here. The US is highly unlikely to meet the 2030 emissions reduction target (a 52% cut below 2005 levels). And the election result will shape what happens at the fortnight-long Cop29 climate summit that began in Azerbaijan overnight.

Beyond that, there is much more we don’t know. Trump wants the country to “drill, baby, drill”, including in Alaska’s Arctic wilderness, but it is unclear what this will mean in practice. Fossil fuel extraction in the US already reached record levels under the Biden administration, much of it for export, before approval of liquified natural gas developments was paused this year. Support for clean energy will survive just because it makes clear economic sense, but it will be a while before the scale is clear.

What we do know is that the most consequential decisions affecting the climate over the next four years will not be made in Washington.

It was already true, but more than ever the most important gauges of climate progress will be what happens in China – easily the world’s largest polluter due to its extraordinary population, rising middle class and role as the globe’s main manufacturer – and how, where and when global investors deploy trillions of dollars in capital.

As always, the Chinese story on the climate crisis is mixed. According to an analysis by Lauri Myllyvirta, a respected China analyst from Finnish thinktank the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air, the country’s domestic emissions have flatlined over the past two quarters, leaving open a slight possibility they could fall this year.

If that happens, it will be a significant moment and ahead of schedule – China’s global commitment is that its climate pollution will peak before 2030 on the way to net zero before 2060. But it will need to do much more to play its part in staving off the worst effects of global heating.

China continues to go big on solar power, having installed 163 gigawatts of new solar (more than twice Australia’s entire electricity capacity) in the first nine months of this year alone. Its solar and wind generation are up 44% and 24% compared with a year ago, respectively. Nuclear power played a smaller role, creeping up only 4%.

After falling for months, its coal and gas-fired generation also rose by smaller amounts in the third quarter as record temperatures prompted people to reach for their air conditioners and ramp up electricity use. But emissions from steel, cement and oil were down as construction activity continued to drop.

The bottom line is that China is easily the world’s biggest driver of renewable energy – it has more than a third of the global capacity – while it also continues pursuing fossil fuel interests. Delegates at the Cop29 talks are watching for signs of whether it will respond to Trump’s return by taking a more aggressive leadership role on climate – not to save the planet, but to advance its strategic interests.

On the question of global investment in non-fossil fuel energy: it has grown dramatically over the past five years, increasing by nearly two-thirds, and is forecast to reach US$2tn this year. Most of the spending is on renewable power and energy efficiency, with support for energy grids and storage making up a smaller chunk and nuclear a much smaller piece again.

The solar and wind component, in particular, will need to continue to expand to meet a global goal of tripling renewable energy capacity by 2030. A potential side effect if Trump delivers on his promise to scrap the huge tax and production credits for clean energy in the Inflation Reduction Act may be that it increases competition between other countries, including Australia, to attract green spending.

All of this hangs over Cop29, where the main focus will be negotiations over a climate finance goal to help the developing world – and how to avoid backsliding on last year’s agreement that the world needs to transition away from fossil fuels.

Unpromisingly, the talks are being held in a petrostate, and the Azerbaijan deputy energy minister has been caught agreeing to help set up fossil fuel deals during the summit. Combined with events in the US, it is the sort of news that can make a cynic of even the most optimistic observers.

My advice? Don’t ignore it, but remember it is not the whole story.

The climate crisis is happening and will get worse, but the drive to limit it and clean up economies continues. There are areas where headway is being made. Just don’t expect it to be a straight line.

Continue Reading

I lost my six year old son when flash floods inundated Nova Scotia – This is climate breakdown | Nova Scotia

Tera works with people who have physical and mental disabilities and lives in the same rural municipality she grew up in: West Hants. When flash floods inundated Nova Scotia, she was working at a group home and raising her two boys, aged six and 11. Those floods would result in the death of her youngest son.

Before the floods, I was always with my boys. Always. I never got a sitter. I wasn’t dating. If I was off on a weekend, I never wanted to let the boys go. We would do all sorts of stuff together: watching movies, going to the park, or outside with the animals. They always wanted to go swimming or the splash pad. We would skip school and go to the skating rink, which I got in trouble for from the principal. If I didn’t get them out of the house, all I would hear was two kids, five years apart, tussling.

They had a strong bond with one another. Alex, my oldest son, would let Colton sleep with him and they would make forts. He’s younger at heart than Colton was. The age gap helped because Alex was like: “I don’t have to grow up so fast.” He’s still anti-girl, whereas Colton was like: “I’ll take all the girlfriends.” He was always a charmer. I would be brushing my hair and even if I looked like crap, he’d go: “Mommy, you’re still beautiful.” He was probably doing it to everybody else because he knew it was just buttering us all up.

Tera Sisco, whose six-year-old son Colton died in floodwaters in July 2023 when an estimated three months’ worth of rainfall fell in less than 24 hours. Photograph: Darren Calabrese/The Guardian

Colton was our glue. I have a lot of pictures of the three of us and he’s in the middle. I have a picture of him standing shirtless in front of a little pile of wood. He was just a hard worker. His brother loved it because he got out of half the stuff that I asked him to do. Where his brother still doesn’t know what he wants to do, Colton knew what he wanted to do. He’s like: “I’m going to do 4-H and I want to do Scouts.” He was still too young to do most of those. He never got those chances.

I knew early on something wasn’t right. All day long, it had thundered. I love thunder and lightning storms, or I should say I loved them.

Colton loved it just about as much as I did. He and I used to listen to thunder and lightning on my phone, put it beside the bed, and we would fall asleep to it. It started around 10am. It’d be light, then it would be intense, and then it’d be light. I found it very strange.

Colton was staying with his father in Brooklyn, Nova Scotia, when flooding started during the night. Photograph: Darren Calabrese/The Guardian

Colton was in and out of the house that day. I had to sleep for a night shift. He was at an age where he could entertain himself and just pop in if he really needed something. His brother was around and capable of watching him. He just prides himself so much in being a big brother.

I didn’t sleep that day. I tried. If I did sleep, I slept maybe 30 minutes. The rain really started around 7pm when I came on shift.

It started raining so hard. I kept checking the radar and it kept saying it was going to end. It never stopped. You wouldn’t even have a break between thunder and lightning. You would see lightning and thunder at the exact same moments. I remember screaming in the middle of my yard the next morning: “Would it just stop fucking raining!?” So much happened in the middle. It was like doomsday. It was like doomsday. I can’t even grasp it to this day.

I touched base with Chris, Colton’s dad. He had just picked Colton up. I don’t know why but I begged him to spend the night at my house. I was like: “Please just turn around. Can you just please spend the night and watch Colton at my house?” I remember Chris saying to me a couple days later I should have just screamed at him. He was like: “No, I’m going to go to Brooklyn [in Nova Scotia].” I said: “Brooklyn’s fine. I know Colton wants to see Natalie.”

Natalie lives next door in the same duplex. He hadn’t seen her in about a month. She was a grade ahead of Colton. Natalie would tell her mom: “Colton’s my boyfriend.” I’m not 100% sure if Colton was really into that. But, for a little six-year-old, he loved saying he had a girlfriend.

Chris touched base with me a couple of times and was like: “We’re going to go to bed.” I was in the mind frame of: “OK, they’re sleeping, they’re fine.” I got my one client to sleep by 12.30am. I had been scrolling Facebook and seen they were calling for an emergency alert on the scanner.

I remember hearing: “I need that emergency alert. I needed it a half-hour ago.” My other client got up just as I heard there was massive flooding in Brooklyn. I was like: I’ll just take care of her and then I’ll call Chris. I wish I had called him then because it took me 15 minutes, and 15 minutes is what he says he would have needed.

I called him at 2.28am. He answered the phone. I think he said “shit”. He was touching water when he put his feet over the bed and got up. He went to the side door and flicked on the porch light. He watched the shed float by the door as I was on the phone with him. He was panicked. It was his voice. It was nothing but panic.

I told him, “Call 911,” and that I would try to call and wake up Natalie’s parents, Nick and Courtney. I did not reach anybody. I called my dad, told him Chris was in trouble, that Chris was going to try and get to his mother’s and call me. That was a call I never got.

After Chris got off the phone with me, he called 911. While he was on the phone with 911, the house started to crack like a tree coming down. It was the water pushing against the house. There was so much water his side door wouldn’t open. He debated if it was shallow enough to put the dog and Colton out the front window. He didn’t want to do that so he went back to the side door. The pressure had eased up enough that the door opened. As he was walking out to the driveway, dog in one hand and Colton in the other, his truck floated away.

When he got to the front of the house, Nick and Courtney were trying to open their door and they couldn’t because of the pressure inside. It took Chris pushing and Nick and Courtney pulling. They got the door open and that’s when Chris watched a tractor-trailer drive through and get taken where his truck had already got swept off into the water. Chris, Nick and Courtney made the decision to get into Nick’s Ford F-450. They put Natalie, Colton, Courtney and her two-year-old son, Christian, in the back seat. They had one dog and Chris’s dogs. They left a cat and a dog named Skye in the house because Skye was too scared. The water just kept rising.

About the series

This is climate breakdown was put together in collaboration with the Climate
Disaster Project at University of Victoria, Canada, and the International
Red Cross. Read more.

Production team

I was dialling phone numbers, trying to get in relief staff. It’s almost like a dream when you’re trying to dial 911 and you can’t hit the numbers. Every number was like that. I couldn’t press the buttons into the phone without having to stop and try it again. I had gone back on to the scanner and I heard there was a family stuck on Highway 14 in Brooklyn along the dyke. I only knew one family there. I knew it was Chris, his neighbours and the kids.

I tried to call Chris and it just went to voicemail. I remember hearing on the scanner that there’s a child in the water. I was hoping I misheard. I walked outside, down the stairs, to check on the other part of the building because there were clients there as well. I was soaked. It was raining so hard. I stopped. I couldn’t move. I was frozen in more than one way. I have never been this cold in my life. I remember saying: “No, Colton. Please no. God, no.” I was pleading with the rain and lightning.

I eventually did move. I went next door and got a hold of another colleague. When she did arrive at 4.30am, I repeated to her: “Grace, he’s gone. He’s gone, Grace. He’s cold. He’s cold. I feel it. He’s cold.” I don’t remember much of that, but I guess I just said it over and over again. In the meantime, my dad called my mom, woke her up, had my uncle go out and get her. When she showed up, I was the same. At about 5am I made my way to Chris’s mother’s with my mom. I waited for the rain to stop. I waited for the thunder to stop. It never stopped.

Around 5.20am I got a call from Truro hospital. I was like: “You have to be fucking kidding me. That hospital’s not close. How am I going to get there?”

The nurse said: “Is this Tera?” I said: “Yes.” She goes: “I have good news. I have Chris here. He’s in shock. But he’s OK.” I remember saying: “That’s great, but what about Colton?” She had said: “Colton?” I went: “Yes, Colton, my son, he’s six.” She goes: “I don’t know. He’s not here. We don’t have him.”

I told my mom I had to go into town. I went to our community centre. The gentlemen said: “There’s just families here.” I was like: “My six-year-old’s missing. I just need to look.” I’ll never forget the whispering looks and faces of concern. He wasn’t there. I went to Windsor hospital. He wasn’t there.

Being desperate but not wanting to bug people trying to help other people, I made my way to the RCMP [Royal Canadian Mounted Police] station where I asked if anybody had found him. I needed to get to Chris. Even though Chris and I are divorced, he was the only one who knew what happened to my baby. He was the only one who knew what happened to our baby.

When my brother picked me up and we started making our way to Truro, we had to drive through Brooklyn. I remember seeing the road, not far around that bend where Chris lived, and it was barricaded. There were emergency vehicles, helicopters, cop cars and people wearing orange everywhere. I had taken Colton’s stuffed duck that he stole from me. It was a gift from a friend. I wouldn’t let go. I was crying. I put the seat reclined back so I didn’t see the water.

Roads and houses around Brooklyn were torn apart in the flood. Photograph: The Canadian Press/Alamy

It was one hell of a drive. There were rocks on the road. There were roads we’d get to and we’d turn around. I remember putting up my seat knowing we were pretty much getting there and looking out the passenger window. There was a fair right in front of the hospital. There was a fucking fair. There was a ferris wheel. There were lights lit up. I just remember going: “Are you kidding me?” I didn’t want to see happiness.

We drove up to a drop-off spot just as Chris was being discharged. I remember hugging him and Natalie’s parents. We went to school together. I remember hugging everybody and crying. We just didn’t have our babies. We didn’t have our children. They didn’t have their little girl and I didn’t have my little boy. We didn’t know what to say. We were just four parents gutted. We get in the car. Chris and I are crying. That’s the first time I realized they didn’t flee in Chris’s truck. He goes: “It was gone.” It took a day for Chris to tell me other facts. I heard bits and pieces of it on the drive home.

The hardest thing for people to understand is that they had nowhere to go. There was no way to get on the roof of the house. They had no hills. They had no high spots. The house was in the middle of a river.

Their only option was the truck. They had to back up to turn around in the driveway, which cost them valuable time. The truck was getting hung up on the new pavement. The water kept rising. They went to turn left out of the driveway and that’s when the current on the left side of the house came so hard that it picked up the nose of the truck.

As it picked up the nose of the truck, somebody said roll down the windows. They cranked down the windows and they got sucked out of the truck. Nobody even had a chance to grab Colton and Natalie. The water gave them no option. Nick went out one window. Courtney and her two-year-old went out one window. And Chris went out the other. Chris was the last one holding on to the truck. It had gone sideways.

Chris had a hold of the window ledge with his foot. Chris lost hold of the truck and was swept away when he tried to throw himself down into the water to get the kids. I’d heard the emergency alert go off at 3.06am, Colton would have been dead almost half an hour.

It was a long drive back home into Windsor. I had friends show up to try and comfort me and Chris. I remember friends trying to make me eat. I remember my eyes hurting.

I think somebody gave me lorazepam. I went to sleep and I did not turn. I woke up around 6am and I thought I heard Colton tiptoeing into my room. I swore it was Colton tiptoeing into my room. He rarely missed sleeping with me. I realized, when I scooched back in my bed and threw the blanket back, he wasn’t there. That’s when I realized that it was real and everything that happened the night before came flooding back.

I got up, grabbed one of Colton’s stuffies, and walked outside. I sat on the front doorstep. Dump trucks started driving by and lining up around the corner. I was like: “What the fuck is going on?” I live on a dead-end road. I walked down and the end of my road was gone. It was gone. A tiny river we have had just taken a road and cut off six houses. At the end of their driveway was a 3ft drop or more. I remember standing there with his stuffy, seeing a neighbour, and the neighbour going: “I’m so sorry.” I walked home and realized my neighbours had taken my animals and taken care of them. I didn’t realize half my shed was ready to fall down.

Tera outside her home in Martock, Nova Scotia. Photograph: Darren Calabrese/The Guardian

I remember my chest was so tight. I couldn’t breathe. I was struggling to process “Colton’s not coming home”.

I remember calling our mental health crisis line. They called me back and went: “Well, our mental health crisis van can meet you at 11.30 but it does not go to rural municipalities. You have to drive to Sackville, maybe Mount Uniacke.” I didn’t want to drive 40 minutes to Sackville. I didn’t want to leave Hants County. All I could remember thinking was: “Why can’t you just come here?”

At this point, I hadn’t told Alex. His dad, Edward, and I had a brief conversation about taking his phone because his friends had Facebook and were starting to message him if Colton was OK. He was 3km away from where Colton died in Brooklyn. My dad went with me and I remember driving around the barricade again and seeing all the people searching. I got to Alex’s dad’s and went in. Alex looked at me and goes: “Something’s wrong.” I went: “Yes.”

I said: “All those helicopters you see and hear that are flying over above you …” He goes: “Yes.” I said: “They’re looking for your brother and they’re looking for Natalie.” I remember him looking at me and going: “Is there any chance they’re going to find him?” I said: “There is a chance, but the more time that goes on, the worse those chances get.” I couldn’t take the hope out of him. He was trying to be hopeful and I just couldn’t do it. He cried, but he cried with a blank look. His eyes just went dark. He wasn’t mad, he wasn’t sobbing. He just had these little tears and he was quiet.

I remember me and his dad hugging him together. We were close. Colton called Edward “Uncle Eddie”. I gave Alex the option to stay with me and he said: “I’m going to stay with Dad.” I said: “OK, I’m going to see how I can help your brother.”

Then and there was when I decided I was going to ground search and rescue. And that’s when I met the head of command, Jason Butler. Jason took me in and showed me where they were searching. He gave me the best update he could and offered to take me on site.

This beautiful field that I once drove by every day was a lake. It was so hot and sunny. I just saw little bits of the truck that the kids were in. The house had moved off its foundation, across the front lawn, and was stopped by a tree. It smelled of rot and feces. The tractor-trailer that went in was filled with processed chicken. Septic tanks had been exposed.

I chose to stay at ground search and rescue as much as I could. They told me, if you see people laughing, don’t take it to heart. If you see people having a nap, don’t take it to heart.” I wouldn’t have given it a second thought. It helped me to see them laughing because Colton was always down for a good joke. It didn’t take me long to start asking how they are doing.

I wanted them to know that I’m Colton’s mom. I am so thankful for you. I encouraged them to nap. I encourage them to rest. I learned to make jokes with them, smile with them, and tell them stories about Colton. I know some people made the comments that I needed to put myself first, but helping people was the best medicine I could have.

A flooded section of Highway 14 in Hants County. Photograph: Imago/Alamy

The next day, my parents showed up with all my family. I remember my uncle coming. He had lost his wife in May. I gave him the biggest hug. I was like: “I can’t help but think that aunt Marlene went because she knew. The only reason I think I’m going to be OK today is because she’s got Colton.” That day was the day they found Natalie. Some people had been searching a beach and found her. She was in the Minas Basin.

I remember going: “Oh God, what if he went out there? No, he has to be in the field.” I remember looking out and going: “He could be anywhere.”

There was so much mud on everything. The mud wasn’t just on the ground. The mud was 10, 15ft up in the air. That’s when it clued in they weren’t just going to walk upon a little boy in a red shirt. They’re going to come across a little boy covered in mud and he wouldn’t be seen right away.

Alex called and asked if he could stop in. He’s always soft hearted and super kind. I made sure he didn’t have to look and see how they were searching for Colton. But he was like: “I want to look.” He met Jason, looked at some of the stuff, and goes: “Mommy, I heard they found someone.” I went, “Yes, buddy, they did.” He goes: “Who’d they find.” I said: “Natalie.” He goes: “Mom, did she say anything about Colton?” I said: “No, she can’t.” That’s when he knew his brother was never coming home. He knew but he just said: “Oh.”

The next day, I got a call from the RCMP. They said: “We finally got the field drained completely. We’re going to search it this morning. Can you not come today just in case?” I said: “OK.” That morning, I had gone to the Superstore. I bought these carnations that weren’t even worth 50% off. They looked like the inside of a piece of salmon. But Colton had wanted to buy them for me before he died. I tried to go to the dollar store to buy these ugly earrings he also wanted me to buy that day. They weren’t there. So I ordered a pair off Amazon the same morning.

I remember Chris and I going to where Courtney and Nick were. I went out on the back deck and I got this strange message on my phone from a friend. She goes: “Where are you at?” I’m like: “Nick and Courtney’s grandmother’s.” I knew the RCMP were hunting me. I remember sitting in that rocking bench. I remember rocking back in it. I remember looking out on to the hill and there were windmills in the distance. I remember looking at the windmills. It wasn’t long before the RCMP showed up and asked for some privacy with us. I remember them sitting down and they said they conducted a search of the field. They found a body. They believed it was Colton and that Colton is dead. I’ve never felt such heartbreak and relief at the same time.

I remember getting upset with the coroner’s office because I didn’t want them to do an autopsy and they didn’t give me a choice.

I remember saying to them: “Fine, can I just identify the body?” They sent a picture through email to my brother because they didn’t think I could do it.

It would have been nice if I had somebody looking out for my interests and helping me advocate for what I want, even if I wasn’t totally right, instead of me just taking the word for it and going: “OK.” I made one request and that was for them to keep him as close to Natalie as possible because I didn’t want them separating again.

Natalie was convinced she was going to marry Colton. They liked lighting off fireworks. They liked fishing in the river. There’s a video of them making a water slide in the backyard. They needed to stay together. They had been beside each other when it happened. They were together and they went together.

From there, the days drag. We had a very small family viewing on Saturday. It was like hitting a wall when I rounded the corner and I just saw his little body in this little white casket. We had him put in his Spider-Man costume and put the carnations he wanted me to have put on his chest. I wanted him to have a piece of his blankie. I didn’t know what I expected when I put his blanket in his hand. I knew it was going to be stiff. But it still wasn’t what I expected.

Hundreds of people came to Colton’s funeral to pay their respects. Photograph: Darren Calabrese/The Guardian

After everybody left, the funeral director and I walked in holding Chris on either side. Chris cried really, really bad. Then, I went back in by myself, knelt down, put my head against the casket, and played with Colton’s hair. His blond hair. I rubbed his chest and talked to him. I closed my eyes. I don’t know if I was asleep. But, seeing him, it was the most peace I’d been in. I must have stayed there for an hour. I remember Chris and the funeral director checking in to see if I was sleeping. I kissed Colton goodbye.

I miss him so much. Working the way I was, I did not realize how much he was there for me. Alex will be like: “Mom, you need to go and have a nap.” But he was doing what he should be doing, which was hanging out with his friends. Colton wanted to be there for me as much as I was there for him. If I was sitting on the couch and looked tired, he’d be like: “I got a blanket, not just for me, but for you too, Mom.”

If he was eating something, he always made a point to share with me. If I didn’t feel like eating, he’d always be like: “Oh, here’s a snack, Mom, I got one for you too.” Colton took care of me. It sounds weird to say it out loud. I’m sure some people don’t realize that until they sit there and think about their own situation and be like: “Whoa.” Colton was the main person taking care of me.

The day we had him cremated, we all went out to the house. Ground search and rescue had been cleaning up that area. The field had been drained. The vehicles had been pulled out. We sat there and threw rocks at the house. There was something therapeutic in throwing rocks at something still standing in that area. We weren’t supposed to go in the house but I did. The floor was all bubbled up. I remember seeing some of Colton’s pictures on the wall and I took them down because I couldn’t stand the thought of them ripping down the house with his pictures in it.

The next day was Natalie’s funeral. Courtney asked me to wear my prom dress because Natalie never got a prom. She wanted everyone to look like a princess.

Somehow, after 13 years, I still fit into my prom dress. Not the most elegant fit. But I wore it. I sobbed so hard during Natalie’s funeral. That’s probably why I didn’t sob at Colton’s. They were back-to-back funerals.

I couldn’t find anything to wear. What does Spider-Man’s mom wear? David’s bridal had given me this beautiful dark blue gown. I overdressed, but Colton wouldn’t have cared. He would have just called me beautiful. He was the only one in the world that ever called me beautiful like that all the time. My dad came out of the bathroom wearing a full-on Spider-Man costume. He says: “Are you OK if I wear this?” It was too tight in an area, but that’s OK. I said: “Dad, of course. I’m not going to tell you not to wear it.”

I chose the church because it was a church I used to attend and I didn’t have to go to Brooklyn. Colton loved the building from the outside. When I got out to go in for his service, there were first responders – ground search and rescue, fire – all lined up. There were hundreds of people. There were people who wore Spider-Man shirts and blue and orange because his favourite colour was blue and orange. We walked down the aisle to Crazy Frog. We played Thunder by Imagine Dragons. I remember saying in my speech: “We debated not playing it, but it is Colton’s favourite song so good luck to y’all.” We played Sunflower by Post Malone because he liked that song too and made us think of him. A little bit of exposure therapy.

The flash floods that inundated Nova Scotia resulted in four deaths in the province. Photograph: Imago/Alamy

I remember telling everybody that it’s OK. I remember addressing Colton’s classmates and Alex’s friends and saying that it’s OK. It didn’t feel right if I didn’t try to talk to Colton’s classmates. I remember saying Colton wouldn’t want us sad forever. I had so many people that needed to know I was thankful and Colton would be thankful. I wouldn’t have this closure and, really, no family would, if it wasn’t for the hundreds of individuals who came forward to help. I got to see Colton. I got to see him one last time.

Jason, who was in command those two days, and deputy fire chief Brett Tetanish, the man I heard on that scanner pleading for that alert, brought my boy home. It came full circle. Jason was paired up with Brett. I hold them very dear to me for what they found, and that was my boy. Because I know it wasn’t rainbows and butterflies.

I’ve had people come up to me since and say I saved lives with what I said at the funeral. That I mentally saved lives. That I’m a hero. I don’t feel like one. They’re my heroes. It really didn’t hit me, until months went by, what some of these people experienced while trying to search for these kids. I didn’t realize how much my empathetic self was helping people. How I handled myself at ground search and rescue was more than just healing for me. It was healing for other people.

That’s when I made Colton’s Facebook page. I post thoughts and opinions on the storm. It’s good for me because I don’t want to let go of it yet. Whether climate change is natural or we’ve sped it up, we’re not preparing ourselves for these weather events. It helps me regulate myself and know he’s not forgotten.

There’s this whole generation of kids that are going to remember Colton. They write notes like: “Oh, Colton. I missed you today. Let’s run for Colton even though he didn’t have cancer.” People should be proud of that and proud of their kids. One day, they’ll remember they had a friend die in such a way. They are going to be like: “This is our world and we got to look out for everyone else.”

We ended the funeral with Bloody Mary by Lady Gaga because Colton liked watching Wednesday Addams and loved singing that too. I hugged people for two hours. Two hours of hugging strangers and political people. Somebody whispered to me: “They found her.” There had been four people that had died. I remember driving to the funeral, looking out the window going: “There’s still somebody missing.” They were calling off the search. But the people who came to Colton’s funeral still didn’t give up. They didn’t give up hope. She had been found in Advocate Harbor. They found her. They found her. I remember the church lighting up through the stained glass windows. It got really bright and I remember thinking: “I’m going to get through this.”

This testimonial was produced with the help of the Climate disaster project; thanks to Sean Holman, Aldyn Chwelos, Darren Schuettler, Ricardo Garcia, Cristine Gerk, Tracy Sherlock, Lisa Taylor.

Continue Reading

Kremlin says reports of Trump-Putin call about Ukraine are ‘pure fiction’ | Donald Trump

The Kremlin has denied reports that the Russian president, Vladimir Putin, spoke to the US president-elect, Donald Trump, calling the media reports “pure fiction”.

The Washington Post first reported that a call had taken place, citing unidentified sources, and said that Trump had told Putin that he should not escalate the Ukraine war. Reuters also reported on a call.

“It is completely untrue. It is pure fiction; it is simply false information,” the Kremlin spokesperson, Dmitry Peskov, said when asked about the call. “There was no conversation.”

“This is the most obvious example of the quality of the information that is being published now, sometimes even in fairly reputable publications,” Peskov said.

Peskov added that Putin had no specific plans to speak to Trump at present.

According to the Washington Post, Trump reminded Putin of “Washington’s sizeable military presence in Europe”. It added that Trump expressed interest in follow-up conversations on “the resolution of Ukraine’s war soon”.

The reported call took place after Putin on Thursday congratulated Trump on his election win and expressed admiration for the way Trump reacted to an assassination attempt during the campaign.

Peskov has a history of dismissing media reports that later prove to be true; most recently, he labelled reports of North Korean soldiers arriving in Russia as “fake news”, despite credible audio and visual evidence confirming their presence. Still, the Kremlin’s swift denial of the phone call with Trump is likely to raise eyebrows, especially given that both leaders have previously expressed openness to dialogue.

Peskov on Monday also accused European leaders of continuing to seek a “strategic defeat” of Russia. Peskov was responding to a question about the possibility that Britain would allow Ukraine to use Storm Shadow long-range missile systems to hit targets inside Russia.

The Kremlin repeatedly said Putin was ready to discuss Ukraine with the west but that it did not mean he was willing to alter Moscow’s demands.

On 14 June, Putin staked out a maximalist position for an end to the war: Ukraine would have to drop its Nato ambitions and withdraw all its troops from all the territory of four regions claimed by Russia.

During the election campaign, Trump said he would find a solution to end the war “within a day”, but did not explain how he would do so. Trump also spoke to the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, on Wednesday, according to media reports.

Washington has provided tens of billions of dollars worth of US military and economic aid to Ukraine since it was invaded by Russia in February 2022, funding that Trump has repeatedly criticised and railed against with other Republican lawmakers.

The US president, Joe Biden, will host Trump for a traditional post-election meeting in the Oval Office on Wednesday, where the current US leader is expected to try to convince the president-elect not to pull support from Ukraine when he takes office.

The meeting will take place against the backdrop of reports that Russia, with support from North Korean soldiers, is planning a significant assault to drive Ukrainian forces out of its western Kursk region.

On Sunday, the New York Times reported that Moscow had assembled a force of 50,000 troops, including North Koreans, in the region bordering Ukraine for an attack. According to US intelligence, 10,000 North Korean soldiers have arrived in Russia, a figure that Ukraine’s military intelligence chief says includes 500 officers and three generals.

In August, Ukraine launched a surprise incursion into the Kursk region, capturing settlements within Russian territory in what was widely seen as a major embarrassment for Putin. However, Russia has gradually recaptured some of this territory and also made steady advances across much of eastern Ukraine.

Continue Reading

Developing world needs private finance for green transition, says Cop president | Cop29

Businesses in the private sector must stump up cash for the developing world to invest in a low-carbon economy or face the consequences of climate breakdown, the president of the UN climate summit has said.

Mukhtar Babayev, the environment minister of Azerbaijan, the host of this year’s climate conference, wrote in Monday’s Guardian: “The onus cannot fall entirely on government purses. Unleashing private finance for developing countries’ transition has long been an ambition of climate talks.

“Without the private sector, there is no climate solution. The world needs more funds and it needs them faster. History shows we can mobilise the resources required; it’s now a matter of political will.”

His words come as scores of heads of state and high-ranking officials from nearly 200 countries gathered in Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan, for the UN Cop29 climate summit, which opened on Monday.

The meeting has been overshadowed by the re-election of Donald Trump, who has vowed to remove the US from the Paris climate agreement and scrap commitments to cut carbon emissions. Scientists have said the world is likely to exceed key temperature limits as a result.

At Cop29, countries will try to forge a new global framework for providing the funds that developing nations need to cut their greenhouse gas emissions and adapt to the impacts of worsening extreme weather. Poor countries want climate finance to ramp up from about $100bn a year today to at least $1tn every year by 2035.

Without the US, developed countries are likely to find targets on climate finance harder to meet. They may seek to reduce the component of publicly sourced money – from overseas aid budgets, and through institutions such as the World Bank – making up the climate finance goal.

That could mean an increased role for the private sector in making up the $1tn target. But that is controversial. Private sector cash comes with strings attached and can drive countries further into debt. It is also harder to access for the poorest countries that need it most, particularly in order to help them cope with the impacts of extreme weather, an activity that few private sector companies have been prepared to fund to date.

In a statement that some parties will find controversial, Babayev wrote: “With competing priorities, there simply isn’t enough money in the world to fund developing countries’ transition to clean energy solely through grants or concessional financing – let alone cover adaptation and loss and damage.”

Many civil society groups are wary of an expanded role for the private sector. Mariana Paoli, the global advocacy lead at Christian Aid, said: “Government finance is so much better than private finance when it comes to tackling climate change. Governments are the only ones able to provide finance in the form of grants, which are the only way to address the growing needs of developing countries to address the climate crisis. Private finance is guided by profits and is almost always loans, therefore worsening the debt crisis that many developing countries are facing.”

She argued that it should not be counted towards the sums developing countries are demanding, known as the “new collective quantified goal” (NCQG) in UN jargon. “Private companies are not accountable to the Paris agreement. Any climate change-related investment they make is welcome but it’s separate from what should be discussed at the talks in Baku,” she said.

However, many developing countries accept that private finance must play a role. A spokesperson for the Alliance of Small Island States said: “At the core of the NCQG is developed countries fulfilling their commitments under the Paris agreement. A key focus is the provision of public finance from developed to developing countries. An additional pillar is the mobilisation of substantive private financing, by specific public interventions of developed countries. The onus must be on the public efforts to advance enhanced finance.”

Simon Stiell, the UN climate chief, told the opening session of the conference on Monday that inflation would result from a continued reliance on fossil fuels and that tackling the climate crisis would also help to tackle economic problems.

“If at least two-thirds of the world’s nations cannot afford to cut emissions quickly, then every nation pays a brutal price. If nations can’t build resilience into supply chains, the entire global economy will be brought to its knees. No country is immune,” he said.

In a veiled but pointed reference to the new presidency in the US, he warned that all countries must play a role. “Let’s dispense with any idea that climate finance is charity. An ambitious new climate finance goal is entirely in the self-interest of every nation, including the largest and wealthiest,” he said.

Continue Reading