Trump says he doesnât expect chaos on election day: âNot from the side that votes for Trumpâ â live | US politics
Key events
Ramon Antonio Vargas
Michigan governor Gretchen Whitmer has apologized for feeding a Doritos chip to a social media influencer who dropped to her knees after Roman Catholic organizations accused the Democratic politician of insulting their religion by mocking the sacrament of communion.
âI would never do something to denigrate someoneâs faith,â Whitmer said in a statement that her office provided to the Michigan television news station WJBK on Friday.
She explained that the stunt in question â captured on video with popular TikTok content creator Liz Plank â was meant to promote legislation signed by Joe Biden in 2022 that is colloquially known as the Chips Act and provided $280bn to research as well as manufacture semiconductors. But it was all âconstrued as something it was never intended to be, and I apologize for thatâ, Whitmer said.
On the video, Plank genuflects before Whitmer, who then places a Doritos chip in the podcaster and influencerâs mouth. The governor caps the scene off by gazing at the camera while she wears a hat supporting fellow Democrat Kamala Harris and her running mate Tim Walz in Novemberâs presidential election.
The Michigan Catholic Conference â which has clashed with Whitmer over her support of abortion rights â joined other church groups in condemning Whitmerâs video with Plank.
More on the controversial video here:
Donald Trump called those who have opposed or investigated him âthe enemy from withinâ.
âI always say, we have two enemies,â Trump said in an interview on Fox Businessâs Sunday Morning Futures. âWe have the outside enemy, and then we have the enemy from within, and the enemy from within, in my opinion, is more dangerous than China, Russia and all these countries.â
He said that what a president might find hard to handle âare these lunatics that we have inside, like Adam Schiffâ referring to the California congressman and US Senate candidate who was part of a House committee that investigated the US Capitol attack carried out by Trumpâs supporters after he lost the 2020 election to Biden.
Tension between Kamala Harrisâs team and Joe Bidenâs White House has been on the rise in the last weeks before the elections, Axios reported.
Senior Biden aides told the news outlet that theyâre still hurt over the president being pushed out of his re-election bid. Bidenâs aides said theyâre adjusting to being in a supporting role on the campaign trail.
âTheyâre too much in their feelings,â one Harris ally said of Bidenâs team.
Former President Bill Clinton visited Albany, Georgia, at an event for the Harris-Walz campaign. Clinton arrived at Mount Zion Baptist church and delivered remarks during the Sunday service.
âExperts in both parties say that this election is coming down to seven or eight states, one of which is Georgia,â Clinton said. âThis whole election and the future of the country is turning out to be what people who are sort of on the fence about voting are going to do in the next three and a half weeks.â
Early voting in the state starts on Tuesday and will run over the next three weeks.
Harris holds a rally in Greenville, North Carolina
Kamala Harris paid a visit to North Carolina, holding a rally in Greenville at East Carolina University a day after her stop in Raleigh.
Over the weekend, she has been meeting with faith leaders and volunteering to help prep supplies for Hurricane Helene victims, which ravaged western North Carolina a few weeks ago.
âI know Heleneâs impact was further west, but I also know that the people of Greenville, like all Americans, have been inspired by the way communities are coming together,â Harris said on Sunday at the Koinonia Christian Center in Greenville.
âIn a moment of crisis, isnât it something when you know that often it is the people who have the least give the most,â she said.
Republican representative Liz Cheney criticized House speaker Mike Johnson for saying there was a peaceful transfer of power to Joe Biden after Donald Trump lost in 2020.
âI do not have confidence that Mike Johnson will fulfill his constitutional obligations,â Cheney said. âHe has a record repeatedly of doing things that he knows to be wrong, that he knows to be unconstitutional, in order to placate Donald Trump. You saw that sycophancy just now.â
Earlier in the show, Johson said: âWe have the peaceful transfer of power.â
âI believe President Trumpâs going to win, and this will be taken care of,â he added.
Edward Helmore
Kamala Harris and Donald Trump spent Sunday trying to shore up political support among what they perceived to be must-have voting blocs with polls showing them locked in a tight 5 November presidential race.
With election day less than a month away, the Democratic vice-president attended a Black church in Greenville, North Carolina, as part of her campaignâs âsouls to the pollsâ push. Her Republican opponent was in Arizona, looking for Black and Latino support as he seeks a second presidency, after a rally in California a day earlier.
Both candidates are attempting to get a decisive edge among votes who have not yet decided who to support. Surveys show that early voting, which tends to favor Democrats, is down 45% from previous election years â a sign that there may be millions of undecided voters.
Trump has now switched from condemning early voting as a Democrat plot to engineer his defeat to Joe Biden in 2020 to urging people to vote early and by mail.
A recent ABC News-Ipsos poll showed that support was split down gender lines, with women voting 60-40 to Harris and men breaking for Trump by a similar margin.
Trump needs white women, who supported him in a greater numbers in 2020 than in 2016 â but also Black men. On Sunday, he argued that his fellow former president Barack Obamaâs call last week for Black men to support Harris based âsolely on her skin color, rather than her policiesâ as âdeeply insultingâ.
Hereâs more on the candidatesâ campaign events:
Trump says he doesn’t expect chaos on election day: ‘Not from the side that votes for Trump’
Ramon Antonio Vargas
Donald Trump on Sunday said he does not expect chaos from his supporters on the day of the 5 November election.
Asked on Fox Newsâs Sunday Morning Futures if he anticipated chaos from those who support him over Kamala Harris, the former president said: âNo, I donât think. Not from the side that votes for Trump.â
Supporters of Trump aimed a deadly attack on Congress weeks after he lost the presidency to Joe Biden in 2020. The US Capitol attack â launched after he told his supporters to fight like hell â was a desperate attempt to prevent congressional certification of the US presidentâs victory.
Hundreds of participants have been indicted on federal crimes pertaining to the violence. And Trump himself was criminally charged with illicitly trying to overturn his 2020 defeat in the lead-up to the attack, including by lying about how fraudsters robbed him of winning against Biden.
Homeland security secretary Alejandro Mayorkas on Sunday said the slew of misinformation online about the hurricanes devastating parts of the US is âextremely perniciousâ.
During an interview with Face the Nation, Mayorkas called for officials to debunk the false claims because âweâre not seeing enough of that.â
DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas says he’s “incredibly concerned” about disinformation around the government’s hurricane response, and that some individuals are not seeking assistance because of it.
“We need individuals, elected officials, people who have the platform, to really⦠pic.twitter.com/pWbJqClaJH
— Face The Nation (@FaceTheNation) October 13, 2024
Democratic committee releases ads calling out Jill Stein as a ‘vote for Trump’
The Democratic National Committee released a six-figure ad campaign in the battleground states of Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania calling out Jill Stein as a âvote for Trumpâ.
The ad opens with a photo of Stein morphing into the Republican presidential nominee.
âWhy are Trumpâs close allies helping her? Stein was key to Trumpâs 2016 wins in battleground states,â says the ad. âSheâs not sorry she helped Trump win. Thatâs why a vote for Stein is really a vote for Trump.â
Democratic party chair Jaime Harrison, California Senate candidate Adam Schiff, activist Jessica Craven, and others reacted to the ad on social.
With so much at stake in November, every vote will make a difference.
So letâs be clear:
AÂ vote for Jill Stein is a vote for Donald Trump. https://t.co/TB1X3obRc8
— Adam Schiff (@AdamSchiff) October 11, 2024

David Smith
Media blitz to VP duties: on the campaign trail with Kamala Harris
The View, Americaâs most popular daytime talkshow, was on commercial break. Kamala Harris sat writing absence notes for students who were missing class to attend the live broadcast. âIs it just today, right?â the vice-president laughed.
She handed over the letters written on notepaper headed âThe Vice Presidentâ. One said: âDear teacher, please excuse Dani from class today. She was hanging out with us. Best and thank you for being an educator. Kamala.â
It was an unscripted moment that the studio audience loved but TV viewers wouldnât see. Harris, running the shortest presidential campaign in modern US history after being unexpectedly plunged into the fight when Joe Biden dropped out, is exploring ways to reveal herself to a wary nation.
Still a relatively unknown quantity, the former California attorney general and US senator is trying to make the electorate feel comfortable about the prospect of President Kamala Harris.
In less than three months the vice-president has raised a record-breaking billion dollars. She has tried to put daylight between herself and the unpopular incumbent figure of Biden, and turn the election into a referendum on her opponent, former US president Donald Trump. She has sought to bring positive vibes to a country that seems to have anxiety in its bones.
She has set out to persuade America to do something that it has never done before in its 248-year existence: elect a woman to the White House â and a woman of colour to boot.
Hereâs more on Harrisâs media blitz:

Stephen Starr
Republicanâs lies about immigrants eating cats in Ohio has led to swell of far-right extremism in Springfield â and beyond
For Denise Williams, the 70-year-old head of Springfieldâs NAACP chapter, the past several weeks have been testing to say the least.
Last month, flyers calling for mass deportations of immigrants were distributed by the so-called Trinity White Knights, a group associated with the Ku Klux Klan, in Black-majority neighborhoods in south Springfield.
âIâm telling people: do nothing â donât approach them. But itâs not easy for people to see this,â she said.
âI think that is what a lot of folks cannot understand â why do we have so much hate?â
About 22% of Springfield residents are African American, according to the US Census Bureau.
âPeople are mad. African Americans here donât understand how this is allowed. We just have to take this for a minute. I know itâs hard.â
Trinity White Knights is headquartered in Kentucky, where flyers were also seen by residents of the Cincinnati suburb of Covington in July as part of an apparent recruitment effort. The flyers included a PO box address in Maysville, Kentucky, and a phone number.
Ever since Donald Trump claimed during a 10 September televised debate watched by 67 million people that immigrants in Springfield were eating peopleâs pets â a claim that has been found to be baseless â Springfield has seen a groundswell in far-right extremism.
Hereâs more context on the rise in far-right extremism:
New polls show Harris either ahead of or head-to-head with Trump
Three major polls were released Sunday, showing Vice-President Kamala Harris either ahead of former president Donald Trump or running a head-to-head race.
Letâs start with the ABC News/Ipsos poll: Harris is ahead by two percentage points with 50% of the support. The poll, conducted between 4 to 8 October, found that 56% of Americans favor deporting all undocumented immigrants, helping Trumpâs lead in trust to handle immigration at the US-Mexico border.
Meanwhile, NBCâs poll, conducted during the same time, shows Harris with support from 48% of registered voters, while Trump has the same percentage of support. Another 4% say they are undecided or wouldnât vote for either option.
CBS also conducted a poll earlier this month, revealing a lead by Harris with 51% support compared to Trumpâs 48%. The economy and policy surrounding the US-Mexico border are among the top issues voters are placing as top priorities when deciding on the next president.
Mike Johnson: more hurricane aid for Helene and Milton ‘can wait’ until after election
Speaker Mike Johnson said that passing additional hurricane aid for states impacted by hurricanes Helene and Milton âcan waitâ until Congress is back in session after the election.
On Sunday, Johnson CBSâs Face the Nation, where host Margaret Brennan asked him why he thinks itâs fine to wait until November for Congress to pass more aid for Hurricane Helene and Hurricane Milton victims.
âWell, it can wait because, remember, the day before Hurricane Helene made landfall in Florida and then went up through the states and wound up in Senator Tillisâs state of North Carolina, Congress appropriated 20 billion additional dollars to FEMA so that they would have the necessary resources to address immediate needs,â Johnson said.
Tillis was part of a bipartisan group of senators that signed a letter urging lawmakers to think about bringing Congress members back into session this month to pass disaster legislation before the yearâs end.
Democratic senator Raphael Warnock from Georgia said he does not believe Black men will show up for former President Trump in large numbers.
During CNNâs State of the Union with Dana Bash, Warnock said:
Black men are not going to vote for Donald Trump in any significant numbers. There will be some. Weâre not a monolith.
He was responding to a New York Times polling that placed Kamala Harris behind Joe Biden among Black voters. Warnock alluded to the late 80s case of the Central Park Five, where the brutal assault of a New York jogger in Central Park led to Trump taking out full-page ads in the cityâs major newspapers calling for the return of the death penalty for those responsible.
âWhen it was proven that the Exonerated 5, the Central Park 5, were actually innocent, Donald Trump has shown no deal of concern about what they went through, no deal, no bit of contrition about it,â Warnock said.
Good morning, US politics blog readers. Thereâs another busy news day ahead of us and weâll keep up with all the developments as they happen.
Donald Trump is scheduled to hold a rally in Prescott Valley, Arizona, later today. Kamala Harrisâs husband, Doug Emhoff, will head to a Get Out the Jewish Vote campaign event in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania. He will later deliver remarks at a Girl Dads for Harris-Walz phone bank in Delaware County.
Several polls released on Sunday show Vice-President Kamala Harris in the lead or in a tight race with former president Donald Trump. An ABC News/Ipsos poll shows 50% support for Harris and 48% for Trump, while the latest national NBC News poll shows Trump and Harris are deadlocked.
Hereâs what else is happening:
-
Kamala Harris on Saturday released a report on her health and medical history, which found that âshe possesses the physical and mental resiliency required to successfully execute the duties of the presidencyâ if voters elect her in November. A senior aide to Harris, 59, said the vice-presidentâs advisers viewed the publication of the health report and medical history as an opportunity to call attention to questions about Donald Trumpâs physical fitness and mental acuity.
-
Tightening poll figures have triggered nervousness and anxiety in Kamala Harrisâs presidential campaign, with Donald Trump making gains in the states where it matters most as the election race enters its climactic final phase, according to The Guardianâs 10-day polling average tracker.
-
Several former Trump administration officials have warned that the former president deliberately withheld disaster aid to states he deemed politically hostile to him as US president and will do so again unimpeded if he returns to the White House.
Tennessee shootout near university leaves one dead and nine wounded | Tennessee
One person was killed and nine others wounded in a shootout amid a crowd near a university in Tennessee Saturday afternoon, police said.
A crowd that gathered earlier in the day for homecoming events at Tennessee State University was beginning to thin out when the gunfire erupted between two groups around 5pm, said Nashville police spokesperson Don Aaron. He said shell casings indicate that gunfire was exchanged across a street near campus between the groups.
The Nashville police commander Anthony McClain said the gunfire didn’t appear to be directly related to Tennessee State University events that had included a parade and other festivities earlier in the day. The football game was taking place in another part of town when the gunfire happened.
“It’s unfortunate that a few folks ruined it for everybody,” McClain said. “We have to come to a point to stop this violence.”
A police statement on social media said a 24-year-old man died. The victims included two 12-year-olds and a 14-year-old with non-critical injuries, Aaron said.
Police spokesperson Brooke Reese said that at least some of the wounded appear to have been involved in the exchange of gunfire.
Police and firefighters who had been present for the day’s activities were able to quickly respond to the shooting, authorities said. Fire department spokesperson Kendra Loney said some firefighters used belts as tourniquets.
Witness Jashawna Rucker told the television news station WTVF that chaos ensued after people heard the shots, and she saw people crying as they ran for safety.
“I am thankful I didn’t lose my life or get shot,” Rucker said.
Rauf Muhammad told the Tennessean newspaper that he was selling food from a tent along the street when he heard the gunfire and dropped to the ground.
“Everybody having fun, music playing or whatnot. Then all of a sudden, you just hear like you off in a war somewhere,” Muhammad told the newspaper.
Earlier Saturday in Oklahoma City, 13 people were shot – including one fatally – during a party. That case as well as the one in Nashville helped bring the number of mass shootings reported in the US so far this year to more than 415, according to statistics from the Gun Violence Archive.
The non-partisan archive defines a mass shooting as one in which four or more victims are wounded or killed.
Constant mass shootings in the US have prompted many in the country to plead for federal lawmakers to provide more substantial gun control, but Congress has largely been unable or unwilling to heed those calls.
SpaceX launches Starship rocket and catches booster in giant metal arms | SpaceX
SpaceX launched its enormous Starship rocket on Sunday on its boldest test flight yet, catching the returning booster back at the pad with mechanical arms.
Towering almost 121 metres (400ft), the empty Starship blasted off at sunrise from the southern tip of Texas near the Mexican border. It arced over the Gulf of Mexico, like the four Starships before it that ended up being destroyed, either soon after liftoff or while ditching into the sea. The last one, in June, was the most successful yet, completing its flight without exploding.
This time, the SpaceX founder and chief executive, Elon Musk, upped the challenge and risk. The company brought the first-stage booster back to land at the pad from which it had soared seven minutes earlier. The launch tower sported monstrous metal arms, dubbed chopsticks, that caught the descending 71-metre booster.
“Are you kidding me?” SpaceX’s Dan Huot observed with excitement from near the launch site. “I am shaking right now.”
“This is a day for the engineering history books,” added SpaceX’s Kate Tice from its headquarters in Hawthorne, California.
It was up to the flight director to decide, in real time with a manual control, whether to attempt the landing. SpaceX said both the booster and launch tower had to be in good, stable condition. Otherwise, it was going to end up in the Gulf of Mexico like the previous ones. Everything was judged to be ready for the catch.
Once free of the booster, the retro-looking stainless steel spacecraft on top continued around the world, targeting a controlled splashdown in the Indian Ocean. The June flight came up short at the end after pieces of it came off. SpaceX upgraded the software and reworked the heat shield, improving the thermal tiles.
SpaceX has been recovering the first-stage boosters of its smaller Falcon 9 rockets for nine years, after delivering satellites and crews to orbit from Florida or California. But they land on floating ocean platforms or on concrete slabs several miles from their launch pads – not on them.
Recycling Falcon boosters has sped up the launch rate and saved SpaceX millions. Musk intends to do the same for the Starship, the biggest and most powerful rocket ever built, with 33 methane-fuel engines on the booster alone. Nasa has ordered two Starships to land astronauts on the moon later this decade. SpaceX intends to use the Starship to send people and supplies to the moon and, eventually Mars.
Limp Bizkitâs fraud lawsuit rattles music industry: âThese accusations are massiveâ | Limp Bizkit
One of the worldâs largest music companies has been accused of depriving âpotentially hundredsâ of artists and bands of their royalties by the 90s nu-metal band Limp Bizkit.
Three decades after it rose to prominence, the band and its founder, Fred Durst, alleges that Universal Music Group (UMG) owes more than $200m after fraudulently concealing royalties from the band.
In a lawsuit filed in California, attorneys representing Durst, Limp Bizkit and Flawless Records accused UMG of using software âdeliberately designed to conceal artistsâ (including Plaintiffsâ) royaltiesâ so it can pocket the profits.
UMG is one of the most powerful forces in the global music industry, with a roster spanning from Taylor Swift and Neil Diamond to Dr Dre and Renee Rapp. The company did not respond to multiple invitations to comment.
Limp Bizkit claims it was not paid âa single cent by UMG in any royaltiesâ until taking legal action, despite a âtremendousâ resurgence in popularity in recent years, with its songs played hundreds of millions of times on streaming platforms in 2024 alone.
The lawsuit, filed in California federal court, claims that many more bands and acts might also be getting shortchanged. Attorneys for Durst, Limp Bizkit and Flawless Records go so far as to suggest that a pre-trial discovery process â in which both sides of a case exchange information â will âshow that potentially hundreds of other artists have likewise been wrongfully defrauded regarding their royalties, showing that the system was intentionally designed to commit fraud on Plaintiffs and other artistsâ.
âThese accusations are massive,â said Jay Gilbert, a music industry consultant and former executive at UMG and Warner Music Group. He is skeptical.
âMy gut tells me that this isnât a systematic scheme to withhold royalties. Itâs more of an accounting issue thatâs blown up,â Gilbert said. âIt sounded pretty damning and pretty heavy-handed, but in my experience, I think itâs something less dramatic.â
This lawsuit was âthe nuclear optionâ, added Mark Tavern, who previously worked at record companies including UMG and Sony Music. âI think itâs designed to force a settlement, and make it happen quickly.â
âItâs a bit over the top,â said Tavern, who now lectures on the music industry at the University of New Haven. âIt can probably be easily explained by bureaucracy, or incompetence,â or the sheer volume of payments processed by a music firm as large as UMG, he said.
Durst claims he was told by UMG that he had not received any royalty statements because his account was still so far from recoupment, with executives at the firm suggesting it had paid Limp Bizkit some $43m in advances over the years, according to the lawsuit.
When representatives of Durst and Limp Bizkit gained access to UMGâs portal for royalty statements in April, however, they claim to have noticed balances that indicated it owed more than $1m.
In August, UMG paid just over $1m to Limp Bizkit and $2.3m to Flawless Records, according to the lawsuit, which says executives blamed the failure to pay sooner on an error with new software.
Questions over royalty payments arise âall the timeâ, according to Gilbert, but rarely explode into the open. âThis sort of dirty laundry is not aired commonly,â he said, with issues typically resolved through audits âbehind the scenesâ.
The global music industry has been rapidly transformed over recent decades, first by the rise of downloads, and then by streaming. Finding and listening to songs has never been easier, thanks to hundreds of millions of tracks that stack the libraries of platforms like Spotify and Apple Music.
Take Break Stuff by Limp Bizkit. It was first released in May 2000, but you might hear it in passing while watching TV, scrolling through social media, or playing a video game. Gone are the days when you would visit a local record store, go through the racks, find the album, and ultimately listen back to the song. Itâs just a few taps away.
Even Limp Bizkitâs attorneys acknowledged that the band â which split up in 2006, and reformed in 2009 â had a ârelatively quiet periodâ in the early 2010s. In the lawsuit, however, they claim that interest in the band began to increase âexponentiallyâ around 2017, leading it to sell out arenas and headline festivals.
âThere is a big pop-punk revival going on,â observed Tavern. âThe current generation [of fans] is looking back 20 or 25 years.â
Such âheritageâ acts and artists, as they are referred to by music industry executives, are prized by record labels.
UMG sought Durstâs approval to reissue Limp Bizkitâs 2000 album Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavored Water on vinyl last year, according to the lawsuit, and ârepeatedly askedâ him to get involved with an anniversary rerelease of Significant Other, another of its albums. To Durst, it seemed like a âmoney grabâ.
The complaint alleges that the plaintiffs are still owed much more than they have been paid. Durst, Limp Bizkit and Flawless Records are demanding a jury trial. Their case is already making waves.
ââEveryone is talking about it,â observed Tavern, who noted the complicated nature of calculating music royalties in the streaming era had led to widespread confusion â and, sometimes, suspicion of the industryâs dominant firms. â
âThe way the money gets paid is totally different now, and much more convoluted,â he said. âYou can point to 450 million streams, but that is not the same as 450 million records.â
Gilbert said: âI think cooler heads will prevail,â suggesting that attorneys for either side would probably meet privately to examine the facts. âThis thing will be resolved,â he said. âI think itâs going to go away.â
Israel is not âsaving western civilisationâ. Nor is Hamas leading âthe resistanceâ | Kenan Malik
âIsrael is not invading Lebanon, it is liberating it.â So proclaimed Franceâs pre-eminent liberal philosopher Bernard-Henri Lévy as Israeli tanks drove across the border and its war planes bombed villages in the south and residential districts in Beirut. âThere are moments in history,â he exulted, when âââescalationâ becomes a necessity and a virtue.â For Lévy, it is not just Lebanon that Israel is liberating, but much of the Middle East, too.
Lévy is not alone in rejoicing at Israelâs spreading military offensive. For many, Israel is waging war, not merely in âself-defenceâ but, in the words of president Isaac Herzog, âto save western civilisation, to save the values of western civilisationâ, a claim echoed by many of its supporters. And the destruction of Gaza, of its hospitals and universities, and the killing of 40,000 people? And the 2,000 people killed in Lebanon in a fortnight, and the fifth of its population displaced? Collateral damage en route to saving civilisation.
I should not need to say this but, as it has become commonplace to portray anyone criticising Israelâs wars in Gaza and Lebanon as supporting Hamas or Hezbollah or celebrating the slaughter on 7Â October last year, let me say that what Hamas did was barbarous, and that, as I wrote at the time, âHamas represents a betrayal of Palestinian hopes as well as a threat to Jewsâ. The same can be said of Hezbollah.
And yet, until 7 October 2023, the prime minister of Israel, and much of his government, was far more supportive of Hamas than I was or would ever wish to be. âAnyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,â Benjamin Netanyahu told a Likud meeting in 2019. âTo prevent the option of two states,â observed former Israeli general Gershon Hacohen, who for years backed Netanyahuâs policy, âhe is turning Hamas into his closest partner. Openly, Hamas is an enemy. Covertly, itâs an ally.â
Israelâs support for Hamas goes back decades, an âattempt to divide and dilute support for a strong, secular PLO by using a competing religious alternativeâ, as a senior CIAÂ agent told UPI more than 20Â years ago. So successful was this strategy that Hamas swept to power in Gaza in 2006, and the Palestinian Authority was cut in two, with Hamas controlling Gaza and Fatah the West Bank.
In recent years, the Times of Israel observed, âIsrael has allowed suitcases holding millions in Qatari cash to enter Gaza through its crossings since 2018â, while practically turning âa blind eye to the incendiary balloons and rocket fire from Gazaâ. On 7 October, it added on the day after the slaughter: âThe concept of indirectly strengthening Hamas went up in smoke.â
Hamas was responsible for the butchery of 7 October. But Israel had helped nurture it for the explicit aim of denying Palestinians a state. And now, in the attempt to undo its previous work, it has laid Gaza to waste. Israel has to enforce âanother Nakba [catastrophe]â, Hacohen insists. âThe Gazans have to be expelled from their homes for good.â
Yet, however cynical it may have been, there was nothing exceptional about Israelâs strategy. For decades, western governments sought to exploit Islam to help pursue their political ends, from the funding of international jihadists to drive out the Red Army in Afghanistan after the Soviet invasion of 1979 to secular France encouraging the building of prayer rooms in factories, regarding Islam, in the words of Paul Dijoud, immigration minister in Valéry Giscard dâEstaingâs government, as a âstabilising factor which would turn the faithful from deviance, delinquency, or membership of unions or revolutionary partiesâ. Such policies often created a space in which more radical Islamist movements could flourish. We are still living with the blowback from this strategy.
Netanyahuâs aim in expanding Israelâs wars, and in threatening to turn Lebanon into another Gaza, is not to âliberateâ anything or anyone but to maintain control, internally and externally. The lessons of previous invasions of Lebanon â in 1978, 1982 and 2006 â should be clear enough. On the first two occasions, Israel invaded to confront the Palestine Liberation Organisation, on the third to try to eliminate Hezbollah, which had emerged, with Iranian backing, in response to the 1982 invasion and occupation. Each invasion was marked by considerable bloodshed â including, in 1982, the massacre of up to 3,500 Palestinians and Lebanese Shia in two Beirut refugee camps, Sabra and Shatila, by Israelâs allies the Lebanese Christian Phalangist militia â and nothing that anyone could call âliberationâ.
There is a deeper issue here, too. In modernity, the historian Ronald Schechter wrote, âJews became good to think [with]â, a comment echoed by David Nirenberg who, in his classic history of âAnti-Judaismâ, similarly observed that âmodernity thinks with Judaismâ. What they meant was that the symbolic roles imposed on Jews became a means of addressing wider social issues. âThe âJewish Questionâââ, Nirenberg wrote, is not âsimply an attitude towards Jews and their religion, but a way of critically engaging with the worldâ.
This use of âthe Jewâ as a means of making sense of the world is most true, of course, of antisemitism. For antisemites, belief in mythical Jewish power explains the evils of the world. It is true also of many strands of philosemitism, a term coined originally by antisemites but which has come to be used more widely to describe the views of those who have particular admiration for the Jewish presence in the world.
after newsletter promotion
And, increasingly, it has become true of perceptions of Israel, which, too, has acquired a symbolic status on both sides of the debate. For many of those hostile to Israel, the state has become totemic of many of the ills of the modern world. For supporters of the Jewish state, it is an especially moral nation, carrying the burden of defending civilisation against barbarism. The one view leads to the celebration of Hamasâs murderous assault on 7 October as âresistanceâ, the other to viewing the destruction of Gaza and the invasion of Lebanon as a necessary defence of western values and of âcivilisationâ.
If 7 October was an act of âresistanceâ, and if the destruction of Gaza and the brutalisation of Lebanon can be dismissed as essential steps towards a more civilised world, then I suggest we need to rethink what we mean by âresistanceâ and âcivilisationâ.
Kenan Malik is an Observer columnist
-
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a letter of up to 250 words to be considered for publication, email it to us at [email protected]
Top-rated UK water firms âdumped 1,374 illegal spills into riversâ | Water
Two of Englandâs biggest water firms dumped raw sewage into rivers across the country in suspected illegal breaches of their permits, despite being given the highest possible rating by the regulator for their environmental performance, the Observer can reveal.
Severn Trent Water and United Utilities were responsible for 1,374 raw sewage spills from sewage treatment works in apparent breaches of permits over a two-year period in more than 80 watercourses, according to an analysis of previously unpublished operational data. It is alleged the suspected illegal discharges were during dry weather or at times when the plants were not at operating capacity.
The two firms were both given the four-star rating by the Environment Agency this year for their performance in 2023. Over the past five years, the firms have paid out a combined £2.8bn in dividends to shareholders and millions of pounds in bonuses to bosses, with both repeatedly citing their top ratings from the regulator.
In response to the revelations, Emma Hardy, the water minister, said: âFor too long, water companies have pumped record levels of sewage into our rivers, lakes and seas. This government will never let this happen again.â
Ashley Smith, founder of the campaign group Windrush Against Sewage Pollution (Wasp), which conducted the studies, said it was shocking the two firms had been given the top rating while apparently âpermitting illegal discharges on a massive scaleâ.
He said: âThese environmental performance assessments lie at the heart of the deceit that has allowed the privatised water industry to pay huge dividends and bonuses.
âThey have been a tick box exercise, providing a cover for profiteering and regulatory failure. It is a national disgrace.â The water firms say the findings are based on âassumptionsâ and consider them unreliable.
The Environment Agency provides an annual assessment of the environmental performance of the nine water and sewerage companies operating in England. Severn Trent has been given the highest rating five years in a row. United Utilities was given the top rating for the years 2020, 2021 and 2023.
In response to the new findings, the agency said a four-star rating does not mean a firm is a âperfect performerâ. It also said it was consulting on changes to the environmental performance assessments.
An agency spokesperson said: âOverall water company performance, including for Severn Trent and United Utilities, isnât where it needs to be and a major area for company improvement is in stopping unacceptable âdry day spillsââ.
Water firms have faced public fury after it was first revealed by the Guardian in July 2020 that they had discharged raw sewage into Englandâs rivers on more than 200,000 occasions in just one year.
The firms are permitted to discharge raw sewage at times of heavy rainfall, but the latest analysis examines potentially illegal spills. The rivers campaign group Wasp matched rainfall records against the water firmsâ operational data for their sewage treatment works (2021-2022) and regulatory permits to expose the scale of the suspected illegal discharges.
Its analysis found that Severn Trent had made 494 suspected illegal spills of sewage in 2021 and 309 in 2022 from 50 sewage plants. One sewage treatment works at the village of Colwall in Herefordshire discharged 72 times in suspected breach of permit conditions in 2021 and 2022.
A treatment works at Derby appears to have illegally discharged sewage into the River Derwent on 35 days over the two-year period, according to the data. There were also suspected illegal spills into the Severn, the Trent and the Cam in Gloucestershire.
Waspâs analysis of United Utilities found the firm had made 308 suspected illegal spills in 2021 and 263 in 2022 from 35 sewage plants. At a sewage works at Newbiggin on Morecambe Bay, which is designated a special area of conservation, there were 84 suspected illegal discharges in 2021 and 2022.
after newsletter promotion
Peter Hammond, the author of Waspâs reports, said there may have been hundreds of other illegal spills by the companies, but the data from the recording equipment in those cases could not be considered robust enough to distinguish between legal and illegal spills. Hammond said that the government âmust replace current devices with flow meters to record frequency, duration and volumeâ. Any bonuses based on unreliable environmental data should be clawed back, he said.
Hammond and Smith, who have been labelled the âsewage sleuthsâ, previously used machine learning to detect untracked sewage discharges, with a paper published in March 2021. Eight months later, the Environment Agency announced its biggest criminal investigation into potential breaches of environmental conditions at sewage treatment works.
Ofwat, the industry regulator, last week ordered water firms to return £158m to customers through bills because of poor performance. Severn Trent and United Utilities, however, were reported to have exceeded their targets and will be able to charge customers more next year.
Charles Watson, chair of the charity River Action, said: âItâs only through the relentless work of citizen scientists that we now know about the state of our rivers while our regulators have been missing in action. The fact that any dividends and bonuses have been paid by firms complicit in persistent widespread illegal activities is an outrage.â
Liv Garfield, chief executive of Severn Trent, was given a £3.2m pay deal in 2023/24, including a bonus of £584,000. Louise Beardmore, chief executive of United Utilities, was paid £1.4m in the year to 31 March 2024, including a £420,000 annual bonus.
A United Utilities spokesperson said: âThe methodology used in this report is not one that is used by regulators or companies and continues to be based on assumptions rather than actual evidence or measured data.â The spokesperson said it understood peopleâs concerns about sewage discharges and had embarked on the âlargest environmental investment in a centuryâ in its infrastructure.
Severn Trent said: âOur sites have complex hydraulic configurations with multiple interdependencies that need to be assessed using site specific assured data, whereas desktop analysis like this can only produce assumptions and unreliable conclusions.
âWeâre making progress to improve river health and an extra £1bn raised by our investors is accelerating delivery, with £450m being invested this year alone to reduce spills.â The firm said it considered the works at Colwall was operating âin line with its permitsâ, and that the Environment Agency performance assessments were âchallenging and intensiveâ and it was the only water firm to achieve the highest rating five years in a row.
A government spokesperson said a new water bill going through parliament will strengthen regulation, including the powers to ban the payment of bonuses to bosses of polluting firms. It will also conduct a review of the water sector.
A spokesperson for Water UK, the trade association for the industry, said: âNo sewage spill is ever acceptable, and we have a plan to put it right. Water companies have proposed investing £11bn to reduce spills by 40% by 2030. We now need Ofwat to give us the green light so we can get on with it.â
Christopher Columbus was Spanish and Jewish, documentary reveals | Spain
The centuries-old mystery over Christopher Columbus’s nationality has been revealed by scientists in a Spanish TV documentary after using DNA analysis.
The 15th explorer was Jewish and from Spain, according to Columbus DNA: His True Origin, a programme broadcast on national broadcaster RTVE on Saturday to mark Spain celebrating its national day and commemorating Columbus’s arrival in the New World.
Researchers led by forensic expert Miguel Lorente tested tiny samples of remains buried in Seville Cathedral, long marked by authorities there as the last resting place of Columbus, although there had been rival claims. The team compared them with those of known relatives and descendants.
Countries have long argued over the origins and the final resting place of the divisive figure who led Spanish-funded expeditions from the 1490s onward, opening the way for the European conquest of the Americas.
Many historians have questioned the traditional theory that Columbus was from Genoa in north-west Italy. Other theories ranged from him being a Spanish Jew, Greek, Basque or Portuguese.
Lorente, briefing reporters on the research on Thursday, had confirmed previous theories that the remains in Seville belonged to the explorer.
He said: “Today it has been possible to verify it with new technologies, so that the previous partial theory that the remains of Seville belong to Christopher Columbus has been definitively confirmed.”
Research on the nationality had been complicated by a number of factors including the large amount of data but “the outcome is almost absolutely reliable,” Lorente added.
Columbus died aged 55 in the northwest Spanish city of Valladolid in 1506 but wished to be buried on the island of Hispaniola that is today shared by the Dominican Republic and Haiti.
His remains were taken there in 1542, then moved to Cuba in 1795 and then, it had been long thought in Spain, to Seville in 1898.
In 1877, workers found a lead casket buried behind the altar in a cathedral in Santo Domingo, the capital of the Dominican Republic, containing a collection of bone fragments the country says belong to Columbus.
Lorente said both claims could be true as both sets of bones were incomplete.
Ukraine war briefing: Zelenskyy says forces are holding positions in Russiaâs Kursk region | World news
Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on Saturday that Russian forces had tried to oust Ukrainian troops from positions in Russiaâs Kursk border region, but that Kyivâs forces were holding their lines. âRussia tried to push back our positions, but we are holding the designated lines,â Zelenskyy said in his nightly video address. Russiaâs defence ministry said on Friday that its forces had recaptured two villages in the border Kursk region, where Ukrainian troops launched a mass incursion in August. Zelenskyy has acknowledged that the Ukrainian advance into Kursk was intended to draw Russian troops away from frontline positions in eastern Ukraine.
Prosecutors in Donetsk region on Saturday said two people were killed in Russian strikes on villages near Kurakhove. The general staff of Ukraineâs military, in a late evening report, reported 47 clashes in the area around Kurakhove and 27 more in the Pokrovsk sector to the north-west. It follows Russiaâs defence ministry on Friday announcing the capture of Ostrivske, a village on a reservoir near the town of Kurakhove, a key Russian target in its advance through the Donetsk region. Ukraine has not acknowledged the loss of the village, but military bloggers have reported Russian advances in the area.
Ukrainian military recruitment officers have raided restaurants, bars and a concert hall in Kyiv, checking military registration documents and detaining men who are not in compliance. Local media reported Saturday that officers intercepted men leaving a concert by Ukrainian rock band Okean Elzy and some were forcibly detained. It is unusual for such raids to take place in the capital, and reflects Ukraineâs dire need for fresh recruits. Raids also reportedly took place in clubs and restaurants in other cities. All Ukrainian men aged 25-60 are eligible for conscription, and men aged 18-60 are not allowed to leave the country.
The Kremlin said on Saturday that the Democrat party presidential candidate Kamala Harrisâs description of Vladimir Putin as a âmurderous dictatorâ exposed how politicians in Washington sought to impose their views on the world. Peskovâs comments appeared to be in response to Harrisâs criticism of a report in a newly released book by US journalist Bob Woodward that Republican candidate and former president Donald Trump, while in office, had sent Covid tests to Russia at the height of the pandemic. In a radio interview, she described Putin as a âmurderous dictatorâ.
Leaders of the group of atomic bomb survivors awarded the Nobel Peace Prize warned on Saturday that the risk of nuclear war was rising, renewing their call to abolish nuclear weapons. âThe international situation is getting progressively worse, and now wars are being waged as countries threaten the use of nuclear weapons,â said Shigemitsu Tanaka, a survivor of the 1945 US bombing of Nagasaki and co-head of the Nihon Hidankyo group. Vladimir Putin signalled last month that Moscow would consider responding with nuclear weapons if the US and its allies allow Ukraine to strike deep inside Russia with long-range western missiles.
Ukraineâs military said on Saturday that it struck a Russian-controlled oil terminal in the partially occupied Luhansk region that provides fuel for Russiaâs war effort. Russian state media reported that the terminal close to the city of Rovenky had come under attack from a Ukrainian drone and said there were no casualties and that the fire had been extinguished, but did not comment on the extent of any damage.
Russian emergency services said they had brought a massive fire under control at the Feodosia oil terminal in Russian-annexed Crimea, which had burned for six days after being struck by Ukraine, state news agency Ria Novosti reported.
Russiaâs defence ministry said 47 Ukrainian drones had been intercepted and destroyed by its air defence systems overnight into Saturday: 17 over the Krasnodar region, 16 over the Sea of ââAzov, 12 over the Kursk region and two over the Belgorod region, all of which border Ukraine. Belgorod governor Vyacheslav Gladkov said Saturday that one person had been killed and 14 wounded in Ukrainian shelling and drone attacks over the previous 24 hours.
In Ukraine, the countryâs air force said air defences had shot down 24 of 28 drones launched overnight against Ukraine. Zaporizhzhia regional governor Ivan Fedorov said two women were wounded on Saturday in Russian attacks on the capital of the southern Ukrainian region, also called Zaporizhzhia.
King Charles and royals fail to reveal official gifts for past four years â despite promise to do so | Monarchy
King Charles and his family have failed to reveal their official gifts for the past four years, despite previously promising to publish an annual list.
Palace officials have blamed the pandemic, the change of reign, and then planning for last yearâs coronation for their inability to publish details of the gifts received by members of the royal family.
The royal familyâs reticence follows controversy over a cash-for-honours scandal involving the kingâs main charitable foundation, which led to a police investigation that was dropped last year without a full explanation from either Scotland Yard or the Crown Prosecution Service. It also comes after revelations that Charles, when he was Prince of Wales, accepted £2.6m in cash in bags from a Qatari politician for another of his charities, the Prince of Walesâs Charitable Fund.
The Duke of York also faced allegations that when he was a working royal he used official overseas trips to conduct private business deals.
But unlike MPs, who have to register gifts, donations and hospitality, there is no public register of interests for members of the royal family. Instead, they act on the advice of their private secretaries in deciding what to declare.
Annual gift lists were introduced after media criticism of attempts by the royal household to conceal the origin of lavish jewellery given to Queen Camilla by a Saudi royal in 2006 and worn by her on an official visit to the US in 2007.
The last annual list, detailing official gifts received by all working members of the royal family in 2019, was published in April 2020 but since then there has been nothing, apart from the occasional description of an exchange of presents during a state visit or pictures when they are given gifts during an engagement.
Over the years, the annual list has led to controversy, such as in 2012 when it emerged that the king of Bahrain and his countryâs prime minister had given a âsuite of jewelsâ to Prince Edwardâs wife, Sophie, while facing criticism over human rights abuses.
But many presents, including sensitive ones, were often concealed, even though official gifts are not the personal property of the royals and are in effect accepted on behalf of the nation.
Saudi Arabiaâs controversial crown prince Mohammed bin Salman gave the Duchess of Sussex a £500,000 pair of diamond chandelier earrings as a wedding present in 2018. In October that year Meghan wore them at a state banquet in Fiji only a few days after the crown prince was accused of ordering the murder of the journalist Jamal Khashoggi. But when journalists asked where she got them, palace officials said they were âborrowedâ. She wore them again that November at a Buckingham Palace dinner to celebrate the then Prince Charlesâs 70th birthday. It was only in March 2021, shortly before the Duke and Duchess of Sussex gave a controversial television interview to Oprah Winfrey, that their true provenance was leaked.
The Prince and Princess of Wales, William and Kate, chose not to release a list of any gifts they had received at their wedding in 2011. Only a handful of official gifts received by Queen Elizabeth for her platinum jubilee in 2022 were disclosed and it is not clear what, if any, were given to King Charles and Queen Camilla to mark their coronation.
It was all very different back in 1947, when the then Princess Elizabeth married Philip Mountbatten. An exhaustive list of gifts to the couple was published and more than 2,500 items went on show to the public.
Charles ordered a formal review of the royal householdâs policy on official gifts in 2003, after a scandal over staff selling unwanted presents. It resulted in clearer definitions as to what constitutes an official gift and a personal present.
Official gifts are those received in connection with official duties or from businesses or individuals not personally known to the family member. They include gifts from dignitaries, such as other heads of state or elected representatives, during events and are not the family membersâ private property.
Personal gifts are those from people they know privately with no connection to official duties.
Graham Smith, chief executive of Republic, which campaigns for an elected head of state to replace the monarch, said: âIt is vital that the public knows about any possible conflicts of interest or attempts to curry favour with royals, as they have direct access to the highest levels of government.â
He added: âCharles and senior royals have access to government papers, can have secretive meetings with ministers and the prime minister and they have leverage to pressure government to do favours for them and their friends.
âThe royals have form when it comes to blurring the lines between whatâs theirs to keep and whatâs an official gift. So full disclosure is needed on whatâs been received and where those gifts are now. If we demand high standards from politicians, we must demand those same standards from the royals.â
A spokesperson for Buckingham Palace said: âThe royal gifts lists will be published in due course.â
Artur Beterbiev beats Dmitry Bivol to win undisputed light heavyweight championship â as it happened | Boxing
Tale of the tape
Hereâs a look at how Beterbiev and Bivol measure up ahead of tonightâs main event. Physically, thereâs not much to separate these former Russian amateur teammates: Beterbiev has the slightest of advantages in reach while Bivol has an even scanter edge in height. Both came in just beneath the light heavyweight division limit of 175lbs at yesterdayâs weigh-in.
Key events
Thatâs all for tonight. Thanks for following along with us and be sure to check out the full fight report here.
âI have to do everything perfect,â Bivol says afterward. âAnd I donât have any explanation because it could look like excuses. I just … Congratulations to Artur and his team. He deserves it.â
Bivol is asked if he felt Beterbievâs power at any point during the fight. He gestures to the ample bruising around his eyes, but notes that most of them came from his own gloves as he blocked his opponentâs offerings.
âHeâs powerful,â he says. âVery powerful. And you see, I have a bruise from my from my hand. [His punching] was so hard, even he reached my eye.â
Would he want to fight a rematch?
âWhy not? Of course,â he says. âIf I had this chance, yes. This is my dream to be undisputed.â
âI donât know why, but I didnât like this fight,â Beterbiev tells the in-ring interviewer. âBut Iâll be better one day.â From there heâs mostly short and to the point.
Was it a tough fight?
âItâs not tough,â he says. âItâs like a little bit uncomfortable. He is world champion, too. He has good skills. But today, Allah chose me.â
What changes did he make during the fight?
âDuring the fight, we always try to change something,â he says. âI wanted to punch him. Maybe thatâs why I delivered more punches. I donât know.â
How does it feel to go the distance for the first time after knocking out 20 straight opponents to start his career?
âItâs a new experience,â he says. âIâm happy that for that. Even Muhammad Ali have fights [that went the] full distance. Iâm not a bad boxer.â
Artur Beterbiev wins by majority decision!
Beterbiev is the undisputed light heavyweight champion of world after winning a majority decision. Two judges handed down scores of 116-112 and 115-113 for Beterbiev while the other had it 114-114 (as did the Guardian).
Round 12
Bivol looked completely tapped out by the end of the 11th round and he doesnât look much better at the start of the 12th. Beterbiev is moving straight ahead, throwing and landing more shots as Bivol conjures every ounce of technique to block, parry and generally fend off a determined opponent with power combinations. A very close round to end a very close, high-level match between two elite competitors. Wonderful stuff.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 10-9 Bivol (Beterbiev 114-114 Bivol)
Round 11
What a fight! Beterbievâs power shots have finally broken through and Bivol is taking an alarming volume of punches. Bivol is moving backwards, visibly fatigues, as Beterbiev stalks forward and lands blows in combination. Bivol tries to tie up his foe in vain and is left in survival mode until the bell. The best round of the fight for Beterbiev, easily. Three more minutes.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 10-9 Bivol (Beterbiev 104-105 Bivol)
Round 10
Bivolâs disciplined defense and technical skill are on full display. Heâs landing the crisper shots while nearly all of Beterbievâs shots are failing to reach the target, mostly landing in Bivolâs gloves. Beterbiev finished the frame strong but it wasnât enough to swing the round.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 9-10 Bivol (Beterbiev 94-96 Bivol)
Round 9
An excellent round by Bivol right when it felt like things were slipping away. Bivol returns to boxing behind that jab and using lateral movement and feints to keep the hard-hitting Beterbiev off balance. Now itâs Beterbiev who is starting to look a little discouraged with three rounds to go.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 9-10 Bivol (Beterbiev 85-86 Bivol)
Round 8
More constant pressure from Beterbiev, finding ways to penetrate his foeâs high guard. Bivol is slowing down and appears to be taking the round off. He tries to steal it in the last 15 seconds, firing off about a dozen unanswered punches, all of which are swallowed up by Beterbievâs guard.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 10-9 Bivol (Beterbiev 76-76 Bivol)
Round 7
A promising start to the seventh for Bivol, who returns to the formula that was working so well for him in the early rounds. Bivol then catches Beterbiev with a left hand flush to the jaw on the back end of a one-two combination. And Beterbiev looks hurt! Bivol is chasing down the puncher. But he overcommits and Beterbiev swings the action back in his favor, trapping Bivol against the ropes and opening up. Heâs lucky the bell sounded when it did. Close round to score but Beterbiev nicks it here.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 10-9 Bivol (Beterbiev 66-67 Bivol)
Round 6
Beterbiev is starting to catch up to Bivol along the ropes more and more often, landing a couple of thudding shots the appear to visibly slow him down. Bivol under intense mental and physical duress at the moment as the hard-charging Beterbiev looks to turn the tide.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 10-9 Bivol (Beterbiev 56-58 Bivol)
Round 5
Beterbiev continues to chart improvement, throwing more punches than Bivol with most of them landing on the younger manâs guard. Beterbiev is relentless in there, in full seek-and-destroy mode and fighting downhill as Bivol continues to jab and counter off the back foot. Bivol lands a crunching left hook with about a half-minute to go but Beterbiev finishes the round with a flurry of activity, doing just enough to shade the round on our card.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 10-9 Bivol (Beterbiev 46-49 Bivol)
Round 4
Beterbievâs plodding, unsparing pressure not quite enough to offset Bivolâs workrate and effectiveness with the jab, but heâs closing the distance incrementally. Another round for Bivol but this will be the test of a lifetime for his stamina and endurance if heâs to keep this up for the scheduled 12 rounds, especially as Beterbiev begins to find a home for his jab.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 9-10 Bivol (Beterbiev 36-40 Bivol)
Round 3
More of the same from Bivol, who is countering beautifully but also opening up and landing some hard shots in combination. But Beterbiev is doing a better job of closing the distance, moving Bivol closer to the ropes with educated pressure and landing punishing blows of his down. Bivol nicks the round but Beterbiev, traditionally a slow starter, is very much in this fight.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 9-10 Bivol (Beterbiev 27-30 Bivol)
Round 2
Beterbiev is doing more to dictate the pace early in the second, forcing the issue and trying to disrupt his opponent from settling into a rhythm. But Bivol is boxing beautifully with the jab, maintaining distance, using lateral movement and scoring points with crisp counters. According to Compuboxâs punch statistics, Bivol is outlanding Beterbiev by a 26-11 edge.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 9-10 Bivol (Beterbiev 18-20 Bivol)
Round 1
Thereâs the bell! Bivol throws the first blow, firing the left jab to keep Beterbiev. Beterbiev on the front foot, looking to counter-punch. Bivol is looking to maintain the distance. After a minute itâs largely a feeling-out round, but a tense one! Bivol is doing more behind the jab, enough to win the first, but both men open up near the end of the frame with Bivol showing heâs not afraid to exchange in the pocket.
Guardianâs unofficial score: Beterbiev 9-10 Bivol (Beterbiev 9-10 Bivol)
The fighters have been announced by ring announcer Michael Buffer. The final instructions have been given by referee Thomas Taylor the seconds are out and weâll pick it up with round-by-round coverage from here!
The fighters are making their ringwalks. First itâs Artur Beterbiev, in a spartan kit of white T-shirt and red trunks, approaching the ring at a full canter as Rizavdi Ismailovâs ÐпеÑед ÐÑ Ð¼Ð°Ñ plays from the arena soundsystem. Now itâs Dmitry Bivolâs turn and heâs making his way to the squared circle at a similarly frenetic pace. Both of these guys canât wait to get started. A quick pause for the national anthem of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Michael Buffer is moving forward with the introductions. Not much longer now.
Ciara, Busta Rhymes and Missy Elliott have taken the stage. From a production standpoint itâs at least on par with a Grey Cup half-time show if not the Super Bowl. The 15-minute spectacular is closed by Missyâs Lose Control with the newly minted Rock & Roll Hall of Famer earning the highest marks of the three by some distance. The fighters should be making their entrances in the next few minutes.
Time change: US TV coverage to start at 5.30pm
Timings update! Top Rank Promotions has announced that US television coverage of tonightâs main event on ESPN+ will now begin at 5.30pm ET â five minutes from now â instead of 6pm as originally scheduled. Remember: thereâs a concert spectacular featuring Ciara, Busta Rhymes and Missy Elliott before we even think about the fighter entrances. What a time to be alive.
The broadcasters for tonightâs main event are spinning their wheels with 40 minutes to go until the main event. DAZN has just brought on Wardleyâs promoter, Queensberry supremo Frank Warren, who said that Clarke suffered a fractured cheekbone in the co-main.
âI went into that first fight with a lot of background stuff, a lot of things,â Wardley said after tonightâs stunning first-round TKO. âWe got them fixed up. We got the game plan right. We put it together [and] executed on the night.
âSometimes, war is needed. Sometimes a little bit of brains is needed. But I took enough assessment from the first fight to know, like I said in all of the interviews, I had success in that war mode. We just needed to cuten it a little bit. We just needed to be a little bit sweeter, put it together a little bit nicer, set things up a little bit better, disguise them a little bit better. But look, I canât help it. War by name, war by nature.
âOnce I have my enemies hurt, thereâs thereâs no help for them unless that bell comes. Thatâs the only thing that will save you.â
Asked what he wants next, the 29-year-old is to the point.
âI want belts, I want titles,â he says. âThese look great and stuff, but I want the ones that say âworld championâ. Whoever else is hunting them, weâre going to have to meet here.â
Tale of the tape
Hereâs a look at how Beterbiev and Bivol measure up ahead of tonightâs main event. Physically, thereâs not much to separate these former Russian amateur teammates: Beterbiev has the slightest of advantages in reach while Bivol has an even scanter edge in height. Both came in just beneath the light heavyweight division limit of 175lbs at yesterdayâs weigh-in.
Fabio Wardley beats Frazer Clarke by first-round knockout!
A sensational first-round knockout in the co-main event at Riyadhâs Kingdom Arena. Wardley detonates a concussive overhand right hand on Clarkeâs jaw that badly hurts the Tokyo Olympic bronze medalist near the end of the opening frame, then unloads until Clarke goes to the canvas in a heap. Clarke makes it to his feet but heâs simply not there and referee Victor Loughlin correctly waves it off.
That means there will be a nearly hour-and-a-half wait until the main event, which cannot begin until 1pm local time (11pm in London, 6pm in New York).
Frazer Clarke has made his way into the ring for his British and Commonwealth heavyweight title bout with Fabio Wardley. Itâs a rematch of their gripping encounter from March, which ended in a draw. This one could very well steal the show.
Our Donald McRae spoke with Clarke in the run-up.
âI wanted to have breakfast with the British title over my lap â and it wasnât there. People donât understand my life and the sacrifices I make, the time I canât spend with my loved ones, my kids who I missed taking their first steps or saying their first words because I was away at a training camp. People never understand how hard it is to be a boxer.â
I show Clarke a photograph of the canvas after his fight with Wardley. It looks like a Jackson Pollock painting where blood rather than paint has been sprayed and splashed across the canvas. âIâve seen that photo,â he says, âand it definitely tells a story and shows the reality of our sport.
âI love boxing but itâs dangerous and I have a beautiful family who come first. That photograph is a little reminder that you donât want it to be your blood. But Iâm human and I wouldnât want to do any lasting damage to anyone.â
Wardley admitted that such fights can take years off a boxerâs career. âIn some cases, definitely,â Clarke agrees. âYou want an exciting fight but you donât ever want one like that.â
Clarke then grins helplessly. âBut weâre fighters and so, in a strange way, I enjoyed it. Then when you look back you think: âBloody hell!â A lot of people ask: âHow do you do it?â The honest answer is I donât know.â
When the draw was announced, Clarke looked more disappointed than Wardley. âI knew it was close but a draw was devastating. Still, Fabio and I had a few words full of respect in the changing room. I thanked him because he brought the best out of me.
âIt was a really emotional night but there was a beautiful moment when I walked into the bar at the Intercontinental, at the O2, to a standing ovation from 300 people. Everyone wanted to buy me a drink. People were singing my name. Fabio walks in two minutes later to silence. That spoke volumes.â
His Excellency Turki Alalshikh has taken the stage to give away a Mercedes G-Wagon. He hits a big red button and the cameras eventually train on to a woman in hijab seated in the north grandstand. Kool & The Gangâs Celebration blasts from the arena soundsystem as she makes her way to the floor to receive the keys. It sure beats the T-shirt cannon!
Jai Opetaia has just stopped Britainâs Jack Massey after Masseâs corner threw in the towel during the sixth round. The 29-year-old Sydneysider has successfully defended his IBF cruiserweight title and it leaves only one more undercard bout: Frazer Clarke and Fabio Wardley for the British and Commonwealth heavyweight title. After that, Beterbiev and Bivol will make their entrances.
Preamble
Hello and welcome to Riyadhâs Kingdom Arena for tonightâs summit meeting between Artur Beterbiev and Dmitry Bivol. There are big fights. There are blockbusters. And there are events like this one which promise to define an era. Tonightâs long-awaited showdown between two unbeaten veterans of the ring and former Russian amateur teammates not simply a delicious clash of styles, but promises to determine generational supremecy in the 175lbs division.
Beterbiev (20-0, 20 KO), the WBC, IBF and WBO light heavyweight champion, is a Russian-born Canadian knockout artist known for his relentless pressure and devastating power. Bivol (23-0, 12 KO), the Kyrgyzstan-born and California-based technician who holds the WBA strap, is better known for deft counter-punching, disciplined defense and ring intelligence. (Ask Canelo Ãlvarez.)
Bivol will look to neutralize Beterbievâs pressure by maintaining distance, using lateral movement and scoring with crisp jabs and counters. Beterbiev will aim to close the distance, cut off the ring and impose his power with in-fighting and body work. The outcome could hinge on who can impose their style on the other.
The main event should kick off in about two hoursâ time. Plenty more to come between now and then.
Bryan will be here shortly. In the meantime hereâs a look at Fridayâs weigh-ins, where Beterbiev (174.9lbs) and Bivol (174.12lbs) both came in narrowly under the division limit.